The Other McCain

"One should either write ruthlessly what one believes to be the truth, or else shut up." — Arthur Koestler

Other People’s Children

Posted on | June 28, 2011 | 36 Comments

One of the easiest things in the world to do is to tell other people how to raise their children. This is especially easy if you have no children of your own.

Looking for blog-fodder at Google News, I saw an interesting headline under the “Spotlight” feature:

How to Talk to Little Girls
I went to a dinner party at a friend’s home last weekend, and met her five-year-old daughter for the first time.
Little Maya was all curly brown hair, doe-like dark eyes, and adorable in her shiny pink nightgown. I wanted to squeal, “Maya, you’re so cute! Look at you! Turn around and model that pretty ruffled gown, you gorgeous thing!”
But I didn’t. I squelched myself. As I always bite my tongue when I meet little girls, restraining myself from my first impulse, which is to tell them how darn cute/ pretty/ beautiful/ well-dressed/ well-manicured/ well-coiffed they are. . . .

The author then goes on to claim — without any actual evidence — that praising girls for being pretty somehow undermines their other qualities. You can read the whole thing.

Whenever I read something completely crazy like that, my first impulse is to ask, “Who’s writing this crap?” And so I checked the author’s bio:

Lisa Bloom, author of Think: Straight Talk for Women to Stay Smart in a Dumbed Down World, is an award-winning journalist, legal analyst, trial attorney, and the daughter of renowned women’s rights attorney, Gloria Allred. . . .

Oh

Whatever Bloom’s qualifications, she’s not a mom, and shouldn’t be telling other people how to raise their children.

Bookmark and Share

Comments

  • Joe

    Lisa Bloom is just going old school with “Children Should Be Seen And Not Heard.” 

  • Pingback: DYSPEPSIA GENERATION » Blog Archive » Other People’s Children

  • Joe

    She does not talk to little girls like that, so they have a healthy body image, but she does have a house made of gingerbread, candy and sweets and loves having children eat it before she pushes them into her oven. 

  • http://thepagantemple.blogspot.com/ ThePaganTemple

    I see what she’s saying. Little girls should be encouraged to focus on traits that they can actually develop and improve on, such as natural, innate talents, things they can develop into actual skills. Appearance is limited and temporary and has little to do with whether or not the vast majority of women will be happy and successful over the long term course of their lives, and in some cases focus on personal appearance can actually be detrimental to a girls long term emotional well-being. Bloom just came across as too fanatical about it and ended up sounded like a hard-core feminist, which she probably is.

  • http://twitter.com/drrogera Roger Anderson

    It would help if people read the article first and found the truth rather than dismissing it because of the Allred association. Having Nancy Pelosi’s daughter tell Bill Maher to stop being so negative was fine with me. My wife brought this article to my attention. She agrees that we could all do better at helping little girls focus on things other than beauty.

     ”Who’s writing this crap?” Of course, what can be expected from a “site” that promotes Rule 5 days. Are you worried your weekly dose of soft-porn will be diminished? Stop putting kids in baskets and start giving them the tools and mentality to be something better than a sex object for you.

  • http://kingshamus.wordpress.com/ KingShamus

    Uh-oh.

    Roger’s sense of humor software just took a shit, causing his knee-jerk comment post protocols to kick in.

    Better reboot the hard drive.  Emphasis on boot.

  • http://www.haemet.blogivists.com Roxeanne de Luca

    From Lori’s article:

    and twenty-five percent of young American women would rather win America’s Next Top Model than the Nobel Peace Prize.

    Um, honey, did you ever think that such a state of affairs MIGHT have something to do with the fact that 25% of young women have zero desire to receive the same accolades as Al Gore, Jimmy Carter, and Barack Obama?

  • Roxeanne ee Luca

    Whoops, Lisa, nor Lori.

  • http://twitter.com/TeachersDiction TeachersDictionary

    Thank you for that hyperemotive and utterly un-persuasive rant.

  • http://twitter.com/TeachersDiction TeachersDictionary

    Because everyone knows that you can’t compliment a little girl’s dress AND encourage her intellect at the same time.

    Neo-Puritanism: It’s Always On the Menu.

  • CalMark

    Old joke:

    There once was a renowned, unmarried expert whose specialty was family psychology.

    His first book was called, “Ten Commandments for Parents.”  

    Then he met a nice woman, got married and had a kid, followed by his second book, “Ten Rules for Parents.” 

    After he had his second child, he published, “Ten Suggestions for Parents.”

    When he and his wife had their third, the expert issued a press release announcing his retirement from the parental guidance business.

  • http://www.redstateeclectic.typepad.com AngelaTC

    (shrugs) Technically speaking from an etiquette standpoint, it is always wrong to comment on the appearance of another, even when complimentary. 

  • http://pointofagun.blogspot.com/ Dave C

    I think it’s safe for me to comment on here because I *do* in fact, have two daughters..  

    I don’t think it’s that big of a deal..    Considering when my youngest loves to play princess dress up.  She’ll come out of her room in a princess dress on and ask how does she look..  

    Do I answer her with:  

    A]  You look like a beautiful princess (the answer she is looking for) 

    or

    B]  Stop with this foolishness.  You need to start reading the Communist Manifesto!  

    or

    C]  (fill in your own answer here)

    [yes, I know the B answer is a bit weighted.  Sue me]

  • Pat

    I think Lisa Bloom does have children.

  • DaveO

    Semi-agree. At a first meeting one doesn’t comment on the other’s appearance. At subsequent meetings, it is polite to compliment if the female has done something new, i.e. hair style. To ignore the new is to cast insult on the female as being unworthy of notice and remark.

  • http://thecampofthesaints.org Bob Belvedere

    Who is writing your crap?

    Cordially…
    Robert ‘Bob’ Belvedere
    Rule 5 Mojo Master, 3rd Degree

  • http://thecampofthesaints.org Bob Belvedere

    Why do they keep allowing this family to breed?

  • Norman Invasion

    “Little girls should be torn from the womb and have scissors jammed into their skulls, not heard.”  –Pretty Much Every Leftist Ever

  • Rosalie

     Every child is different.   Some need a bit more praise than others.  It really comes  down to knowing what your child needs and common sense.   What’s wrong with saying that a dress is pretty?   Or that a child is pretty?   Maybe the problem stems more from who these girls look up to in Hollywood – superficial stars who are obsessed with their appearance.

  • Joe

    And Roger, I sure when your wife asks you how she looks before you go out somewhere you tell her that looks don’t matter. 

  • Anamika

    C]  (fill in your own answer here)

    “Hey, grow up already! I already keep worrying about marrying you off  (when you reach marriageable age)!”

    Sounds right, Dave?

  • http://pointofagun.blogspot.com/ Dave C

    STFU

    &

    FOAD

    Think that covers it. 

  • Asscheeks of Saturn

    Did the kid look like The Terminator?

  • El Kilo

    I would say that  if my dog looked like Anamika I’d shave her ass and make her walk backwards, but that would be wrong.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1385852725 Richard Mcenroe

    *sigh* Other people’s children.  Can’t talk to ‘em, can’t punt…

  • Joe

    Being a feminist and leftist means if you are too young or too old you don’t have rights any more. 

    So they get you coming or going. 

  • Anamika

    Lucky dog, but unlucky master–who doesn’t own one that looks like Anamika.

    Btw who do you reckon would win the Wimbledon men’s? I hope Nadal will be fit enough to meet Federer in one more epic final.

  • Beau

    Every time my kids fall and hurt themselves, even if they bleed, i say: “quick, quick, nobody will pick you up, stand up and smile!” the risk of nurturing “Princess Precious” in an adult is as high as in a kid…

  • Anamika

    You’re joking right?. That’s just plain twisted.

    Ok, you’re French, I understand. But that’s no excuse either.

  • Anamika

    Love your babies….comfort them when they are wounded….be the father you wish you had……They are precious jewels…as are you.

  • Beau

    In the school yard the kids are falling all the time and there are a hundred of them, some stand up immediately and keep playing, others are glued to the ground and wait for mommy.

  • Anamika

    …Right. And soon they learn mommy isn’t coming. If at that point they do not already know that they are loved, most likely they will just become bitter.

    The best way to prepare them for being alone in the schoolyard and falling down when you aren’t there is to raise them so that know they are loved and cared for.

    If the demand on them is only to “grow up”, “be strong and fearless” they will never get that they are loved. The ones that get up right away may only be doing it because they have been shamed into it.

  • AnnaY

    Well, I am new here and have only read a few blog post discussions. However, I find it very stimulating. Typically, I don’t post much at all.

    Anamika, I have to say I think you are right on. Most parents try to do a good job. And of course, we can all look back and wish we had done it better.

    Sure we want our children to grow up strong and independent. That is a pretty damn tough order without providing the emotional security they need. I think you are right on in your remarks and my remarks are not meant to be a judgment or criticism.

    I sure did a lot of dumb things like listening to my mother who told me not to pick up my son when he was crying. I figured she knew better than me though she had never been a good parent to me. But what did I know about being a mother…nothing. I figured she at least knew more than me. I did not learn until he was grown that an infant or child being picked up when they cry instills trust, a sense of security. They are less fearful if they are trusting and get that basic need met in early childhood.

    Just my opinion and remarks from a woman who failed miserably as a parent.

  • Pingback: GayPatriot » Conservative politicians’ children

  • Anonymous

    Shut your hatehole, you ignorant slut.  Nobody asked your opinion, and it’ll be a cold day in hell before anyone here wants it.

  • johnl

    Telling a girl she’s pretty is redundant and wont make you stand out from the rest of the boring old people her parents invited over. Ask her about her dog, dolls, or favorite book and you will be the life of the party. You might spend the rest of the night throwing the ducky and being read to, but that’s hardly a worst case scenario.

Performance Optimization WordPress Plugins by W3 EDGE