One Hundred Years Ago
Posted on | June 23, 2014 | 26 Comments
Anniversaries often slip my attention. A.O. Scott has a long essay in the New York Times about World War I, which began in August 1914, so that we are now living in the 100th anniversary of the last summer of peace before that bloody atrocity.
Scott points to a startling fact: On July 1, 1916, opening the Battle of the Somme, the British suffered 60,000 casualties in a single day.
We simply cannot imagine such a thing nowadays. Total U.S. combat deaths in the Iraq War were less than 5,000, with another 32,000 wounded. In the worst month of fighting in Iraq — November 2004 — there were fewer than 140 American troops killed.
Probably the best book about World War I is The Guns of August by Barbara Tuchman, which won a Pulitzer Prize for non-fiction.
Comments
26 Responses to “One Hundred Years Ago”
THE FULL METAL JACKET REACH-AROUND AWARD
This spot rotates to honor those who link us in shameless obedience to Rule 2 of "How to Get a Million Hits on Your Blog."
HIT THE FREAKING TIP JAR!
Search
Recent Posts
- Georgia: How’s ‘Jim Crow 2.0’ Working?
- In The Mailbox: 11.04.24
- Rule 5 Sunday: Pre-Coffee Lounging
- FMJRA 2.0: No Expansion This Year
- Election 2024: Be Prepared for Anything
- Election Fraud: Democrat Firm Identified as Source of Suspicious Voter Registration Forms in Four Pennsylvania Counties
- In The Mailbox: 11.01.24 (Evening Edition)
- In The Mailbox: 11.01.24 (Afternoon Edition)
- Vote Trump, and the Media Will Die
- In The Mailbox: 10.31.24
Click here to manage your email subscription options.
RSS reader subscription
MEMEORANDUM
Recent Comments
- OK, who did not see this coming? | If You are Left you ain't Right on Aspiring Rapper Update
- The Club Can’t Even Handle Venezuela Right Now | vulture of critique on In The Mailbox: 07.29.24
- Goodbye, Blue Monday | Animal Magnetism on Rule 5 Sunday: Hangar Queen Double-Scoop Sunday!
- Why don’t we put violent predators away forever? | If You are Left you ain't Right on ‘Ghost’ Gets 28 Years in Federal Prison
- Sorta Blogless Sunday Pinup - Pirate's Cove » Pirate's Cove on In The Mailbox: 07.26.24 (Evening Edition)
THE AMAZING GONZO FEED
Major Leagues
ADVERTISEMENT
Axis of Fedorables
- All-American Girl for the Restoration of Values
- Allergic to Bull
- Cat House Chat
- Chris Cassone
- Conservative Daily News
- DaTechGuy
- Fishersville Mike
- Girl on the Right
- Haemet
- Hogewash
- Just A Conservative Girl
- Marooned in Marin
- Paco Enterprises
- Sissy 'put moi in your blogroll' Willis
- So It Goes In Shreveport
- SWAC Girl
- The (Perhaps Slightly Less) Lonely Conservative
- The Camp of the Saints
- The World's Youngest Blogger
- Uncoverage
- VA Right
AMAZING SAVINGS NOW!
Archives
- November 2024 (9)
- October 2024 (47)
- September 2024 (43)
- August 2024 (55)
- July 2024 (63)
- June 2024 (59)
- May 2024 (48)
- April 2024 (43)
- March 2024 (55)
- February 2024 (46)
- January 2024 (45)
- December 2023 (53)
- November 2023 (62)
- October 2023 (57)
- September 2023 (56)
- August 2023 (53)
- July 2023 (69)
- June 2023 (67)
- May 2023 (53)
- April 2023 (60)
- March 2023 (73)
- February 2023 (65)
- January 2023 (56)
- December 2022 (60)
- November 2022 (64)
- October 2022 (58)
- September 2022 (68)
- August 2022 (75)
- July 2022 (69)
- June 2022 (73)
- May 2022 (74)
- April 2022 (57)
- March 2022 (79)
- February 2022 (65)
- January 2022 (58)
- December 2021 (62)
- November 2021 (68)
- October 2021 (73)
- September 2021 (63)
- August 2021 (60)
- July 2021 (80)
- June 2021 (64)
- May 2021 (64)
- April 2021 (58)
- March 2021 (73)
- February 2021 (57)
- January 2021 (71)
- December 2020 (77)
- November 2020 (81)
- October 2020 (84)
- September 2020 (94)
- August 2020 (75)
- July 2020 (68)
- June 2020 (83)
- May 2020 (77)
- April 2020 (65)
- March 2020 (85)
- February 2020 (94)
- January 2020 (95)
- December 2019 (88)
- November 2019 (60)
- October 2019 (113)
- September 2019 (91)
- August 2019 (91)
- July 2019 (88)
- June 2019 (80)
- May 2019 (74)
- April 2019 (97)
- March 2019 (100)
- February 2019 (85)
- January 2019 (93)
- December 2018 (90)
- November 2018 (83)
- October 2018 (96)
- September 2018 (79)
- August 2018 (107)
- July 2018 (98)
- June 2018 (86)
- May 2018 (78)
- April 2018 (78)
- March 2018 (97)
- February 2018 (61)
- January 2018 (70)
- December 2017 (62)
- November 2017 (68)
- October 2017 (67)
- September 2017 (70)
- August 2017 (68)
- July 2017 (52)
- June 2017 (60)
- May 2017 (56)
- April 2017 (80)
- March 2017 (80)
- February 2017 (102)
- January 2017 (104)
- December 2016 (65)
- November 2016 (86)
- October 2016 (77)
- September 2016 (81)
- August 2016 (66)
- July 2016 (83)
- June 2016 (81)
- May 2016 (65)
- April 2016 (64)
- March 2016 (81)
- February 2016 (74)
- January 2016 (66)
- December 2015 (64)
- November 2015 (85)
- October 2015 (71)
- September 2015 (80)
- August 2015 (67)
- July 2015 (79)
- June 2015 (69)
- May 2015 (72)
- April 2015 (94)
- March 2015 (122)
- February 2015 (71)
- January 2015 (93)
- December 2014 (99)
- November 2014 (67)
- October 2014 (109)
- September 2014 (87)
- August 2014 (106)
- July 2014 (132)
- June 2014 (154)
- May 2014 (126)
- April 2014 (145)
- March 2014 (144)
- February 2014 (142)
- January 2014 (185)
- December 2013 (192)
- November 2013 (174)
- October 2013 (175)
- September 2013 (181)
- August 2013 (172)
- July 2013 (147)
- June 2013 (135)
- May 2013 (128)
- April 2013 (105)
- March 2013 (162)
- February 2013 (191)
- January 2013 (206)
- December 2012 (190)
- November 2012 (176)
- October 2012 (240)
- September 2012 (206)
- August 2012 (235)
- July 2012 (223)
- June 2012 (161)
- May 2012 (230)
- April 2012 (269)
- March 2012 (282)
- February 2012 (247)
- January 2012 (267)
- December 2011 (285)
- November 2011 (300)
- October 2011 (302)
- September 2011 (297)
- August 2011 (288)
- July 2011 (297)
- June 2011 (245)
- May 2011 (260)
- April 2011 (344)
- March 2011 (293)
- February 2011 (201)
- January 2011 (263)
- December 2010 (265)
- November 2010 (266)
- October 2010 (305)
- September 2010 (280)
- August 2010 (272)
- July 2010 (230)
- June 2010 (244)
- May 2010 (256)
- April 2010 (222)
- March 2010 (271)
- February 2010 (286)
- January 2010 (229)
- December 2009 (21)
- October 2009 (1)
Free Agents
SHAMELESS CAPITALISM
The Other McCain is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for this blog to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
Triple-A Franchises
- All-American Blogger
- American Power
- Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler
- Athens & Jerusalem
- Barney Quick
- Bartholomew's Notes On Religion
- BatesLine
- Bear Creek Ledger
- Bearsears Patriots
- Blog de KingShamus
- Bride of Rove
- Cold Fury
- Daily Pundit
- Dr. Helen
- I Own The World
- Legal Insurrection
- Moe Lane
- No Runny Eggs
- Obi`s Sister
- Protein Wisdom
- Rhetorican
- Small Dead Animals
- The Conservatory
- The People's Cube
- The Sundries Shack
- VodkaPundit
- Vox Day
- Zilla of the Resistance
Blogroll
- 90 Miles From Tyranny
- A Conservative Shemale
- A Point of View
- Adrienne's Corner
- AmSpec Blog
- Bad Blue
- Blazing Cat Fur
- Calvin Freiburger Online
- Carol's Closet
- Catholic Bandita
- Caught Him With A Corndog
- Cecil Calvert
- Common Cents
- Conservative Hideout
- Conservative Watch News
- Conservatives for America
- Conservatives For Palin
- Crazy For Liberty
- Dad 29
- DC Damsel
- Dr. Flap
- Dyspepsia Generation
- Effing Conservatives
- Election Dissection
- Eric Reasons, IT Genius
- Eye of Polyphemus
- Finding Ponies. . .
- Free Will
- Grandpa John's
- Granite Grok
- GrEaT sAtAn"S gIrLfRiEnD
- Hoosier Access
- John William Perry
- Judicial Watch
- Jumping in Pools
- KURU Lounge
- Laughing Conservative
- Makes My Brain Itch
- Marathon Pundit
- Martin Eisenstadt's Blog
- Media Fade
- Michael Leahy
- Mister Pterodactyl
- Naked Villainy
- Nice Deb
- noot's observatory
- Not One Red Cent
- Okrahead
- Ollieander
- Pileus
- Pinup Girl
- Point of a Gun
- Political Pit Bull
- Reaganite Republican Resistance
- Red Alexandria
- Red State Eclectic
- Red, White & Conservative
- Republican Redefined
- ResCon1
- Ric's Rulez
- Ricochet
- Right of Course
- Robipedia
- Robomonkey
- Ruby Slippers Blog
- Saberpoint
- Scared Monkeys
- Sentry Journal
- SI VIS PACEM
- Skepticrats
- Smash Mouth Politics
- Sooper Mexican
- Taking Hayek Seriously
- Tel-Chai Nation
- Tequila & Javalinas
- The Aged P
- The Classic Liberal
- The Izzy Report
- The Minority Leader
- The NeoSexist
- The Nose on Your Face
- The Republican Mother
- The Right Sphere
- The Saint Angilbert Press
- The Snooper Report
- The Underground Conservative
- Thunder Tales
- Tom McLaughlin
- Tory Anarchist
- TrogloPundit
- Vets On The Watch
- Watcher of Weasels
- Western Experience
- World's Only Rational Man
- WyBlog
- Yankee Phil
- Zingstrom's Blog
June 23rd, 2014 @ 3:48 pm
Tuchman’s book is indeed outstanding. I’ve been meaning to reread it.
Back in 1999, the various news magazines were discussing who should be “Person of the 20th Century.” My vote was for Gavrilo Princep, the Serbian twerp whose murder of Franz Ferdinand started the ball on WWI. Everything that happened in the 20th Century after that June day in 1914 can be traced back to that moment.
June 23rd, 2014 @ 4:26 pm
Tuchman’s book is the standard. Also, Solzhenitsyn’s August 1914, which details how all the fabled blunders appeared as they happened in the real world. Virtually every decision by every side was based on miscalculations.
Imagine Nicholas II had declined to intervene on behalf of the Serbs. He might have pursued some limited reforms at home, there would not be the monstrous war to turn the bourgeoisie against him, no Bolshevik Revolution. But there would also have been no pact with Hitler for Germany to violate, so Hitler would have had only the one front to fight.
June 23rd, 2014 @ 4:48 pm
And the way the Allies got around those atrocious numbers was restriction of information to the press. Just like they did during the Civil War and later in WWII. It was only after the war(s) that the full impact became available.
I am not saying that is necessarily a good thing. Accountability leads to lower casualties. But too much accountability, or rather too much emphasis on casualties over goals, leads to paralysis.
June 23rd, 2014 @ 4:50 pm
In truth, the Serbs agreed to most of the Austrian demands–certainly enough for the Austrians to save face. Additionally, the absence of a Bismarck to advise Wilhelm II, didn’t help either.
June 23rd, 2014 @ 4:53 pm
But like the butterfly effect (in that any change, however small, will completely alter the outcome over time of a complex system), a tiny change back then would probably meant no Hitler. There may have been a subsequent conflict between France/England and Germany, but without the personality of Hilter as “Der Fuhrer” who knows how that might have turned out. I am guessing less horrific. But it is pure speculation, we just don’t know.
June 23rd, 2014 @ 4:56 pm
Keep in mind that it is 150 years since the siege of Petersburg. Good to draw parallels there.
June 23rd, 2014 @ 5:03 pm
First, I believe that Martin Gilbert’s “First World War” is much superior to Tuchman.
Second, Hitler would have attacked Tsarist Russia, just as surely as Marxist, Leninist, Stalinist Russia. And his rise to power was not dependent upon the Bolshevik revolution. (This is what I hate about alternative histories, an willingness to face the awful facts.)
June 23rd, 2014 @ 5:42 pm
As the mother of two sons, 22 and 18, I am very conscious of “What if we were living 100 years ago?’ and what would lie ahead. As a matter of fact, I pointed that out to my 8th graders: if we were living 100 years ago, some of them would be going off to fight in 3-4 years.
June 23rd, 2014 @ 6:19 pm
Hell, Hitler would have still been painting post cards in Vienna!
June 23rd, 2014 @ 7:37 pm
I hear that the series started by Max Hastings is, so far, very, very good.
And don’t forget Winston Churchill’s take.
June 23rd, 2014 @ 8:26 pm
My pet, and completely unprovable, theory is that if the Confederacy had either been allowed to secede peaceably, or had won its war of independence, World War II, at least in Europe, would never have happened.
Why? Because the USA, considerably weaker without the CSA states, would not have entered World War I, and Germany would either not have lost the Great World War, or had an armistice on much less draconian terms. Thus, even if Corporal Hitler hadn’t been killed in that much longer war, Germany would not have been so ripe for the radical movements of the 1920s which brought the Nazis to power.
June 23rd, 2014 @ 10:06 pm
I started “A World Undone” by AJ Meyer earlier this month in anticipation of the 100th anniversary of the start of the war.
This war shaped the 20th and 21st centuries and caused unimaginable suffering and grief.
How different the world might have been if only the Austrian royal family had not so despised Sophie, Duchess of Hohenberg.
June 23rd, 2014 @ 11:28 pm
Here, NYTimes May 13, 1918 – Casualty list
http://distantcousin.com/military/wwi/nytcasualties/1918/may/13marines.html
Scroll to the bottom, MIA Ray Howard Aseltine. That would be my maternal grandmother’s older brother. He was actually captured by the Germans while on patrol between the trenches in Verdun. He and one other were the only survivors taken as POWs.
Everyone assumed he was dead until he was turned out into the countryside after armistice. The horrors he went through and witnessed were pretty stark (somewhere I have a copy of a letter he dictated from a hospital bed to let his family know he was alive).
June 23rd, 2014 @ 11:31 pm
The ironic thing was that Archduke Ferdinand was considered to be a reformer, unlike his father, Franz Josef. In any case, if it wasn’t Gavrilo Princip, it would have been someone or something else. The Great Powers, particularly France and Germany, were looking for a once-and-for-all showdown.
A great book describing the machinations leading up to WWI is Robert K. Massie’s “Dreadnought”, especially regarding the fraying of the once-close alliance between England and Germany, which was chiefly due to the antics of the borderline insane Wilhelm II.
June 24th, 2014 @ 2:04 am
Yes, Churchill had a unique perspective on several wars!
June 24th, 2014 @ 5:50 am
Franz Joseph was Franz Ferdinand’s uncle.
June 24th, 2014 @ 6:08 am
You are correct, sir.
June 24th, 2014 @ 8:50 am
Dreadnought is very, very good. It’s also on the “reread” pile next to my easy chair.
June 24th, 2014 @ 12:47 pm
The French were certainly spoiling for a fight. They remembered the humiliation of the loss in 1871 which wrested Alsace and Lorraine from them. Had Germany and France gone round and round, London would have been quite happy.
The other side of that, however, that brought the Brits in was Wilhelm building a blue water Navy that was beginning to challenge the Royal Navy in numbers. The Brits did not like anyone on the continent challenging them on the sea and the building of a blue water navy by Germany made the imperialists in London very nervous.
Wilhelm was anything but insane, nor were his “antics” close.
June 24th, 2014 @ 12:51 pm
If Russia had not intervened for Serbia, then it is unlikely that any of the other bad stuff would have happened. Without a German loss and the punitive Versailles treaty, the atmosphere that allowed the rise of the NSDAP would not have existed and there would be no Hitler or WW1 loss to avenge.
June 24th, 2014 @ 12:54 pm
One can go back and check the firestorm over the casualties at Tarawa to see what can happen in such situations. It didn’t paralyze us in going across the Pacific, but it gave very serious pause to the country and the military leaders in the Pacific.
June 24th, 2014 @ 12:57 pm
I remember a passage in MacArthur’s “Reminisces” about being given orders to take a hill or, as the CG told him “give me a list of 5,000 casualties.”
In WW1, such a list could be produced in mere minutes. By comparison, we lost 400,000 in almost 4 years of WW2.
June 24th, 2014 @ 7:50 pm
At this point, allow me to recommend _The Myth of the Great War_ by Mosier. Mosier has a compelling analysis of the war not caught up in Allied post-war mythologizing. (And I would argue that the conventional view of the war, nicely expressed by the article Mr. McCain links is integral to the Progressive Techno-socialist political perspective.)
June 24th, 2014 @ 7:55 pm
There was scandal in Britain when educated Britons became aware of the casualty reports from the German Army medical service. Even today, there is a great reluctance to accept that casualty rates on the German side of the Western front were much lower than those on the Allied side.
June 25th, 2014 @ 11:41 am
[…] One hundred years ago was just a few weeks before Europe got engulfed in World War I: July 1, 1916: The British suffered 57,470 casualties that day… […]
June 28th, 2014 @ 9:32 pm
[…] One Hundred Years Ago […]