The W-Word: Fringe Journalism Is Fun!
Posted on | July 1, 2010 | 52 Comments
Yes, the W is for ”Weigel,” which term seems to have become as offensive (or boring) to some readers as “epistemic closure” or even “Elena Kagan Sex Tape” — the latter being a sort of satire of Rule 5, for which Marty Eisenstadt disclaims any responsibility.
Summer is a great time for blog-fights because traffic always goes down during the summer anyway, and you might as well be in a pissing match as trying to get people to pay attention to politics on the cusp of the Fourth of July. (Why do you think Pat Leahy scheduled the Kagan hearings now, anyway?)
This summer’s Weigelian Götterdämmerung generated some interesting spin-offs, including John Hawkins’ feud with David Frum, Dan Riehl’s kiss-my-ass to the D.C. Republican establishment, and Andrew Breitbart’s $100,000 “Let’s Make a Deal” bid for the Journolist archives:
Does anybody really care about this stuff? Frankly, we don’t know, because nobody’s reading blogs three days before Fourth of July. Obviously, the traffic-suckage has reached critical mass when even Instapundit resorts to traffic-baiting with an Andrew Sullivan beatdown.
Not that I’m against Sully beatdowns, but at some point, you get tired of repeating that the obstetric-obsessed marijuana-addicted immigrant poofter appears to be descending into AIDS-related dementia. Even Ace of Spades seems to be growing weary of rolling Sissy Fuss up that hill.
Dale Robertson and Chuckles the Clown
OK, so . . . David Weigel. People who say that Weigel never did the Right any favors are giving short shrift to an episode recounted by Ikeonic:
I didn’t know Dave Weigel from a hole in the wall until January 2010. At that time, I was researching and blogging about an idiot named Dale Robertson — who was caught holding this sign at a Houston Tea Party event. Dave Weigel broke the story for a wider audience and it was picked up by Chuckles at Little Green Footballs . . .
Weigel’s original story reported this reaction from the Houston Tea Party Society:Update: Josh Parker of the Houston Tea Party Society tells me that Robertson was booted out of the event for this sign.I thought to myself: Wow, now there’s a newsworthy nugget that Chuckles seems to find irrelevant in his zeal to tar and feather all Tea Partiers as racists. . . .
Even Media Matters reported the Houston Tea Party Society’s repudiation of Robertson because Dave Weigel reported on it! Some folks at Houston TPS were kind enough to give me some praise for blogging on their behalf, but it was really Dave Weigel who got the Houston TPS their due in a way I never could have with my miniscule following.
When the online Left, and even the Washington Times, tried to elevate Robertson as a “Tea Party Leader,” Weigel pushed back against this clearly erroneous meme. Dave didn’t do that to curry favor with anyone, but simply because this raaaaacism smear was a bogus hit-job, an illegitimate narrative that was being exploited to perpetuate a falsehood.
From the Fringe to the Mainstream
Several of my friends have pointed to Weigel’s habit of covering the fringes of the conservative movement, the goofs and nutballs and tinfoil-hatters. “He’s just interested in making us look bad,” seems to be the basic complaint.
Actually, I think this points to Weigel having the same Hit-’Em-Where-They-Ain’t instinct that drives a lot of my reporting expeditions. Rather than engaging in pack journalism — jumping on the big Story Of The Day that everybody and his mother is already covering — there’s more news opportunity (and a lot more fun) in reporting stuff that isn’t yet on the radar of the mainstream press.
Why, after all, did I go racing off to Kentucky to debunk the “Lower Glennbeckistan” angle on the Census worker hanging? Why did I start rattling the tip-jar to go cover Doug Hoffman in NY-23 almost as soon as I got off the phone with his campaign?
Hit ‘em where they ain’t: Find a developing story that deserves more coverage and then jump into it neck-deep.
That approach to reporting works no matter what the story is. Who was the first music critic to see the breakthrough potential of the Ramones or REM or Nirvana? Better yet, who set out on an expedition to North Wilkesboro, N.C., in 1965 to cover a hillbilly pastime that now rivals the NFL as America’s favorite sport?
In politics, the hit-’em-where-they-ain’t approach means keeping an eye out for long-shot candidates and marginalized movements. The nature of American politics is that today’s kooky fringe is tomorrow’s rising insurgency and perhaps next year’s power structure.
Obama’s early association with the fringe leftovers of the ’60s New Left (Bill Ayers, et al.) led to a successful campaign fueled in large measure by the same anti-American kooks who thought Ned Lamont would make a good senator. Glenn Beck has become a TV star and bestselling author in large measure by chronicling shady connections among members of today’s Democratic/Progressive coalition – connections once known only to readers of publications that most reporters would dismiss as “right-wing fringe” – including WorldNetDaily, David Horowitz’s Discover the Networks and the John Birch Society’s New American magazine. (Hey, who has the lowdown when the story is a Russian spy?)
Whatever Weigel’s sins, his reporting on the Dale Robertson meme shows that at times he performed the valuable journalistic service of separating the factual wheat from the bogus chaff in MSM coverage of the Right. I’ll also remind you of Liz Mair’s suspicion that Weigel got burned by a progressive on Journolist for the “sin” of defending Rand Paul.
And by doing such things, Weigel pissed in Charles Johnson’s cornflakes.
So he can’t be all bad, can he?
Comments
- Estragon
- Estragon
- http://theothermccain.com smitty
- http://theothermccain.com Robert Stacy McCain
- http://ak4mc.us/cms/ ak4mc
- http://ak4mc.us/cms/ ak4mc
- http://theothermccain.com Robert Stacy McCain
- Adobe Walls
- Adobe Walls
- Joe
- Joe
- Joe
- Joe
- Joe
- Joe
- http://pointofagun.blogspot.com/ Dave C
- http://pointofagun.blogspot.com/ Dave C
- http://freealabamastan.blogspot.com Paul A’Barge
- http://freealabamastan.blogspot.com Paul A’Barge
- http://ikeonic.blogspot.com Ikeonic
- http://ikeonic.blogspot.com Ikeonic
- http://www.southtexian.com Mike LaRoche
- http://www.southtexian.com Mike LaRoche
- http://thecampofthesaints.wordpress.com Bob Belvedere
- http://thecampofthesaints.wordpress.com Bob Belvedere
- http://thecampofthesaints.wordpress.com Bob Belvedere
- http://thecampofthesaints.wordpress.com Bob Belvedere
- Joe
- Joe
- Joe
- Joe
- http://thecampofthesaints.wordpress.com Bob Belvedere
- http://thecampofthesaints.wordpress.com Bob Belvedere
- http://ikeonic.blogspot.com Ikeonic
- http://ikeonic.blogspot.com Ikeonic
- JadedByPolitics
- JadedByPolitics
- Adobe Walls
- Adobe Walls
- http://www.ordinary-gentlemen.com E.D. Kain
- http://www.ordinary-gentlemen.com E.D. Kain
- http://thecampofthesaints.wordpress.com Bob Belvedere
- http://thecampofthesaints.wordpress.com Bob Belvedere
- Estragon
- Estragon
- http://ikeonic.blogspot.com Ikeonic
- http://ikeonic.blogspot.com Ikeonic
