The Other McCain

"One should either write ruthlessly what one believes to be the truth, or else shut up." — Arthur Koestler

Jared Loughner: Reefer Madness?

Posted on | January 18, 2011 | 48 Comments

The Tucson massacre provides arch-Tory Peter Hitchens an excuse to stick his thumb in the eye of libertarians:

The most likely cause is Loughner’s daily cannabis-smoking habit. The link between this drug and serious mental illness grows clearer every day. Wickedly, the dope lobby still tries to deny this and seeks to legalise it.
Loughner has been, for much of his short life, a habitual smoker of this so-called ‘soft’ organic drug. This is not in doubt. Police records, the testimony of U.S. army recruiters who rejected him partly on these grounds, and the accounts of several friends confirm that Loughner is a marijuana victim.
Yes, I know. Not all cannabis-smokers lose their minds. And not all cigarette-smokers get cancer. [Oooh! Taking shot at his brother Christopher? -- RSM] But in both cases the risk is enough to cause concern.
When police caught him driving a car that stank of marijuana, Loughner was let off,
as he would have been here. So much (as usual) for the non-existent ‘war against drugs’.
Cannabis is now effectively legal in Britain and in several parts of the USA, where this dangerous and unpredictable poison is ironically permitted for ‘medical use’.
Arizona voters, fooled by years of cynical and shameful ‘cannabis is harmless’ propaganda, approved just such a stupid law in November.
The town council of liberal Pima (scene of the murders) last week took the first step towards licensing ‘dispensaries’ for dope.
Arizona has always had plenty of guns. America has always had heated political rhetoric. What is new is that it now has legal dope as well.
Those who are seriously interested in public safety should worry less about guns and radio shock jocks, and more about the little packets of madness on sale in every school.

Certainly a controversial opinion, but let me ask you try something. Take five minutes to watch the opening sequence of Zeitgeist and tell me if you don’t see its psychedelic element:

If you have any background in psychology, would you say that young people under the influence of marijuana — or salvia divinorum or cocaine or psilocybin, which were among the drugs Loughner reportedly used — are highly suggestible?

And did you notice what happened in that video from 2:45 to 3:05? A man writes “1+1 = 2.” A Bible is laid down, and a U.S. flag is laid atop it. Then, fading in over the red-and-white stripes of the flag, we see scenes of the jet flying into the World Trade Center on 9/11.

What does it mean? What is being symbolized and suggested by that 20-second sequence? Why do you think the drug-addled Jared Lee Loughner was so obsessed with Zeitgeist? And what ideas did it convey to him?

Understand that it is not necessary, in the case of a schizophrenic, to single out a single factor in his madness. Dan Collins writes with the authority of experience:

As other observers have pointed out, [Loughner's] age when he began gradually to withdraw is consistent with the usual onset of schizophrenia — in the late teens and early twenties. We also know that among those who are genetically inclined towards schizophrenia, the use of marijuana makes it significantly more likely that they will suffer an onset episode. Mercifully, I don’t have to go through a full recitation of the evidence, because Salon . . . has interviewed the psychiatrist author of Surviving Schizophrenia, Dr. E. Fuller Torrey, who lays out the case as elegantly as anyone could. . . .

Dan delves into the difficulty of decoding the typical “word salad” gibberish of the schizophrenic:

Jared Loughner’s ideolect is inflected with bits and pieces of deconstructive linguistic theory. The basic idea is that words only refer to other words, in a closed system of signification. . . . There is no “objective” (at least human) “reality” apart from the signification conferred on it by language. It depends on the definition of what “is” is. . . .

Read the whole thing.

UPDATE: Welcome, Instapundit readers! You may remember that, on the day after the Tucson shootings, Time magazine’s Joe Klein went on CNN and used what proved to be a very poor choice of words:

“I have used that very word, crap, to describe what appears on Fox News. . . . [T]he conspiracies that Glenn Beck promotes create this notion we’re about to fall off of the abyss, that helps to create a zeitgeist where nuts are empowered.”

You know who else hates Fox News? Yeah: The makers of Zeitgeist.

UPDATE II: Linked by The Lonely Conservative — thanks!

UPDATE III: Linked by Jacob Sullum at Reason‘s Hit & Run blog, where I contributed this comment:

Yeah, dopeheads are giving me hell in the comments on that blog post. This suggests to me that long-term marijuana usage makes people hypersensitive to criticism. I’m thinking about reporting their ISP addresses to the DEA and the FBI just to see the headlines: “ONLINE DRUG RING BUSTED.” Then the SWAT squad will kick in their doors, and Radley Balko will have another one of his cops-run-amok stories.
Crazy? Yeah. But wouldn’t it be fun?

It’s important to play on the paranoid fears of these drug-crazed hippies. Make ‘em sweat, see? Every time they see a clean-cut, thick-necked guy in a dark sedan, they need to be thinking it’s a plainclothes narc doing surveillance, ready to serve an arrest warrant. And, hey, stoner – you see that van parked across the street? How do you know it’s not full of M-16-wielding SWAT cops getting ready to raid your house because they noticed your electric bill’s gone up since you put all those grow-lamps in your basement?

They’re coming to get you, dopehead scum!

You’d better flush your stash down the toilet now, before it’s too late, or else you’ll be handcuffed, locked up and sent to the state penitentiary.


Bookmark and Share

Comments

  • Joe

    Self medicating with dope when one has schizophrenia is more a symptom than a cause. It is probably likely Loughner would not have killed if he was being treated with the proper medications, but we won’t ever know that because he was not being treated at all, was not in the mental health system, and was basically allowed to run wild until he completely flipped out and murdered people.

    What I find ironic is how your car can stink like dope and you do not get even a cursory DUI sobriety test, but dare have two glasses of wine and watch out!

  • Anonymous

    Unstable mind meets lots of drugs and lots of bad info. Hilarity does not ensue.

  • http://rightnetwork.com Van der Leun

    Okay, here’s a tip or a lead to follow: “marijuana — or salvia divinorum”.

    It’s not a fixed “either / or” situation. Salvia is sold in wads of leaves AND tincture form. As a tincture, it is easy and possible to dose marijuana with salvia and come up with a hybrid with really nasty psychotic effects.

  • http://rightnetwork.com Van der Leun

    The Salvia high is short-term and rotten enough as an experience… something a sane you wouldn’t want to repeat. (Trust me on this one.) However, it could be extended and boosted by a marijuana joint laced with it. Just the sort of idea a schizoid teen would come up with.

  • http://racetrackdegenerate.blogspot.com Degeneratevern

    Mindless drivel!

  • http://pointofagun.blogspot.com/ Dave C

    A man writes “1+1 = 2.” A Bible is laid down, and a U.S. flag is laid atop it. Then, fading in over the red-and-white stripes of the flag, we see scenes of the jet flying into the World Trade Center on 9/11.

    What does it mean?

    Can I give it a try?

    That coupled with the evolution animation shown right before hand means that mankind has evolved, developed religion, government and will soon kill us all with war.

  • Pingback: 'Far Right' Zeitgeist Hates Fox News | The Lonely Conservative

  • Pingback: Instapundit » Blog Archive » TRIGGER HIPPIE: Jared Loughner: Reefer Madness?…

  • grandma caesar

    “According to the National Survey on Drug Use and Health, in 2009, 16.7 million Americans aged 12 or older used marijuana at least once in the month prior to being surveyed, an increase over the rates reported in all years between 2002 and 2008.” so we should expect a few million more murders, due to this “dangerous and unpredictable poison”.

  • Anonymous

    Eh. I’ve never had a negative experience with salvia. It’s a rather ho-hum hallucinogen, one that I’m pretty sure is only used because only because all the superior alternatives are illegal.

  • Tman

    “Arizona has always had plenty of guns. America has always had heated political rhetoric. What is new is that it now has legal dope as well.”

    It is? Dope is legal? Maybe that’s why there haven’t been that many incidents like the one in Arizona during the recession.

    Man, walk away fr

  • Anonymous

    I’m not sure what position Stacey is taking here, but that happens a lot. He has dethroned Glenn Reynolds as the prince of passive-aggressive blogging. Sometimes I think – no, no, I know – that he’s just trolling. You know, for the lulz.

    Anyway, I’m not afraid of the truth. If Loughner smoked the evil weed and it drove him to murder and listen to negro jazz, I can accept that. So on one hand we have six deaths that were caused in part by marijuana use. On the other hand, we’ve got many more deaths resulting from cannabis prohibition. On balance, the death toll isn’t even close.

  • Anonymous

    Here, let me help you with this:

    Possible Explanation A: Jared Loughner saw a Sarah Palin “target” map and decided to shoot people.

    Possible Explanation B: Jared Loughner watched Fox News and decided to shoot people.

    Possible Explanation C: Jared Loughner was a mentally disturbed man who did a lot of drugs, became obsessed with a New Age “progressive” conspiracy-theory film and decided to shoot people.

    Among these three possible explanations, for which one can we adduce actual evidence?

    “I won’t go schizo, will I?”

    “It’s a distinct possibility.”

  • Tman

    So this means Reefer Madness?

    It wasn’t Sarah Palin it was weed?

    That doesn’t make any sense either. Tons of people smoke weed and they aren’t shooting everyone.

    How about we just go with “Jared Loughner was a mentally disturbed man who decided to shoot people”.

    The end.

  • Aussie54

    @Grandma Caesar, no, not every teen who tries pot once will end up as a schizophrenic. The key is the “inherited tendency”.

    If you look at the information regarding Loughner’s father, I would bet that he has a mental illness of some sort because he has not worked for 22 years. It is a guess by me, nothing more.

    I have had plenty of interaction with people who have been pot smokers and who have descended into mental illness. At least one has attempted suicide.

    What is really important is that it looks like he was using the pot and the salvia divornium together. The symptoms described by classmates are typical of salvia divornium.

    So yes, in a minority of cases, where there is an inherited tendency for mental illness, the smoking of pot can be the trigger of schizophrenia.

    My evidence is anecdotal, but I have never seen a proper study of the possibility that the smoking of pot leads to schizophrenia.

  • Aussie54

    I .

    There are two possible drugs that can impact the onset of schizophrenia: pot and speed.

    I have known several people who used drugs and became mentally ill. Some of them were pot smokers, and some took other drugs.

    Until there are studies that are not based upon the biases of the researchers re the possible effects of pot, we cannot say for certain one way or the other, but there is ample evidence that those who have the inherited tendency of schizophrenia are more likely to end up with that particular mental illness if they become users.

    What sets Loughner apart is that he was using other drugs at the same time, and it would seem that the combination of those drugs more than likely is causal for schizophrenia.

  • Aussie54

    I agree and I honestly think that the Salvia Divornium had a very big impact upon his mental condition. There is a lot of information on Wikpedia, even though I take issue with some comments that were made in the article.

  • Aussie54

    I agree and I honestly think that the Salvia Divornium had a very big impact upon his mental condition. There is a lot of information on Wikpedia, even though I take issue with some comments that were made in the article.

  • Aussie54

    no one said that he had a negative experience with the salvia divornium. It seems that this is how he altered his mind.

    What we are saying is that there seems to be a link between the salvia divornium, the pot smoking and Loughner’s apparent descent into schizophrenia.

  • Aussie54

    It was not the weed that caused him to attempt to kill Gabriella Giffords.

    It was a certain combination of factors – the smoking of pot (and we have no idea the strength of that pot) as well as the use of salvia divornium and other drugs. It also includes the possible tendency for inherited mental illness.

    Whilst millions of people can smoke pot on a less than regular basis and with no ill effect, for some there is that danger that its use will trigger mental illness. Even so, the point here is that there was more than one drug being used, and that use seems to have precipitated the descent into what looks like paranoid schizophrenia.

  • Mike C

    According to his rap sheet, Loughner was hospitalized for alcohol poisoning in 2006.

    I blame the lingering effects of alcohol. Anyone who has seen an episode of “Cops” knows that beer causes domestic violence.

    Seriously, I think Tman hit the nail on the head.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_L62HCT57N7PJBWIVQKNTWWK37A Sharon Kleitman

    Everyone seems to assume this guy was crazy. This is only because he murdered six people and tried to kill more, for no obvious reason.
    But all murderfive ers are not crazy.
    Think about this guy. He had no success with women. He failed at five jobs had no way to support himself.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_L62HCT57N7PJBWIVQKNTWWK37A Sharon Kleitman

    (continued) He had no present and no future prospects, He had painted himself into a corner with no way out. What was left for him?
    Two possibilities only: suicide or prison. What would you do with no life and no means of support? Is seems to me to be perfectly rational to do something to get committed forever.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_L62HCT57N7PJBWIVQKNTWWK37A Sharon Kleitman

    (continued) and his drug taking (though perhaps not the marijuana) undoubtedly contributed to his systematically ruining all his hopes for the future. Certainly it caused the army to reject him.
    No question he was an odd ball and showed zero social skills. No doubt he was to preoccupied with his own problems to make sense to others..

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_L62HCT57N7PJBWIVQKNTWWK37A Sharon Kleitman

    but that doesn’t mean that he had no rational motive for his crimes.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_Y72TJATBNXTNDUDMUOW6WZF5RY tdperk

    “The most likely cause is Loughner’s daily cannabis-smoking habit. ”

    A far more likely cause is that he quit smoking in the months before the massacre, as witnessed by his peers. It wasn’t the pot that made him crazy, it going off the pot.

  • Pingback: Jared Loughner: Reefer Madness? : The Other McCain | The Daily Conservative

  • Anonymous

    Or getting off marijuana allowed him to get off the couch and go do something. Something evil for sure.

  • Brian Macker

    Article is stupid drivel. Out of the millions who’ve smoked pot and the presumably thousands of those who have real mental issues we only get one guy who shoot people up. Sounds like a much better record than Christianity. Is there a connection there? I doubt it in either case.

  • Brian Macker

    Don’t let facts get in your way. From an interview it is quite apparent that Jared wasn’t using pot at the time. Perhaps he should have stayed on his medications:

    “Tierney was happy for his friend: “I said, ‘Dude, that’s awesome.’ And the next time I saw him he was 10 pounds lighter.” Tierney never saw Loughner smoke marijuana again, and he was surprised at media reports that Loughner had been rejected from the military in 2009 for failing a drug test: “He was clean, clean. I saw him after that continuously. He would not do it.”

    After Loughner apparently gave up drugs and booze, “his theories got worse,” Tierney says. “After he quit, he was just off the wall.” “

  • Brian Macker

    A lunatic with a machine gun. Just what we need.

  • whatever

    You do realize that the demonization of weed is ridiculous and dangerous. Once someone uses it and finds out that, as I did, everything I’ve been told about weed is a lie, what else are the control freaks misinforming people about other drugs. Weed has been called a gateway drug. Well duh, once you lie to people they start experimenting on their own.

    From my little social circle that does back thirty years, ten of the 12 are daily smokers of weed. Only 2 a blue collar workers, of the rest we have a vice president of a Fortune 500 company, a national sale director of the second largect company in its field, an individual trader who does quite well and three business owners, two of which they started from scratch. There is one who would rather live on the streets, an refuses any help, he was one of the non smokers.

    Your need to find justifacation for a nut job is amusing. But hey, blame it on us druggies.

  • Anonymous

    You do realize that the demonization of weed is ridiculous and dangerous. Once someone uses it and finds out that, as I did, everything I’ve been told about weed is a lie, what else are the control freaks misinforming people about other drugs.

    Your anecdotal testimony — “Just Say ‘Yes,’ Kids!” — would be far more persuasive if you would provide us with your actual name, and the names of others in your “little social circle” of long-term weedheads, so that your assertion that you and all of these people are fine, upstanding citizens could be checked.

    For myself, I first got high in 1974 at age 14 — it was some killer Columbian — and within a year was actually dealing the stuff. That was back in what can only be described as The Great Stoned Age. The year I graduated high school, a survey showed that marijuana use among teens had reached an all-time high, and I doubt it’s ever been surpassed. (This was the era depicted in the film Dazed and Confused.) Back in the day, I used to buy dope by the pound and sell it by the quarter-pound, so I am certainly not unfamiliar with the Ways of the Weed. But I stopped smoking dope when it went past $40 an ounce retail, and haven’t missed it at all.

    Getting high is a waste of time and money, is what it is. That young people working for $8 an hour should be spending their money to buy weed — what is it now, $140 an ounce? more? — is a horrible misallocation of resources. Is it really good for teenagers to spend a substantial portion of their time in a stupified haze?

    And as for you: You’ve been getting high for 30 years, so you are clearly addicted to the stuff. It’s obviously impaired your sense of humor, so that you are unable to shrug off criticism of the drug you so persistently crave, but feel the need to justify your habit to others. Have you sought counseling for this problem?

  • whatever

    Don’t get me wrong RS, I agree with you on the misallocation of resources and we really don’t go around telling our kids smoking weed is great, rather caution them that drugs of any kind is tough on a developing body and intellect.

    Why would I go out of my way to out me and my friends, so that a hater can go after them. I may smoke weed but stupid I ain’t.

    Addicted, really? You claim to have smoked. Did you get counseling. Is that how you got away from it? I suspect it had more to do with the misallocation of resources and running a foul of the law that prompted you to quit, assumming you did sell. And $140 an oz., I wish, double it and you are getting close.

    Look, I come home from work and take a few hits. I don’t drink, I don’t do other drugs, legal or other wise. I don’t smoke till my mind is “stupified haze.” I have a very good sense of humor, I just didn’t realize that this piece was suppose to be humorous. Funny but the whole point was what you highlighted. You misinform the kids about the effcts of weed, then they try the harder drugs because they feel that they have been misinformed about the about the effects of crack or meth.

    Yo paraphrase what I said most times a nut job is just a nut job.

  • Pingback: Reefer Madness Spreads to the U.K. - Hit & Run : Reason Magazine

  • Anonymous

    The latest scientific thinking on schizophrenia is that it is caused by a retrovirus endogenous to the human genome.

    http://discovermagazine.com/2010/jun/03-the-insanity-virus/

    The use of marijuana and alcohol by schizophrenics is almost invariably an attempt to self-medicate. Don’t take medical advice from Britishers, the NHS has ruined them.

  • Anonymous

    Tons of people smoke weed and they aren’t shooting everyone.

    Not yet. But the Great Weedhead Rampage might begin at any moment. Some dopehead gets the munchies, goes to 7-Eleven and finds out they’re out of his favorite donuts and next thing you know …

  • Tman

    “The great weedhead Rampage”

    Now THAT is funny. The only thing weedheads would “rampage” is a box of ding-dongs and Call of Duty. I realize you’re going for the snark factor here, but your admitted history with weed has given you a bias against those who didn’t turn in to drug dealers like you when they smoked weed. You would be shocked -SHOCKED I TELL YOU- at the number of widly successful people in business and entertainment who smoke a whole lot of weed. None of them turned in to drug dealers or psychopaths. But I suppose this kills your buzz, so it’s easier to just ignore that reality and play the asshole who wants to scare people who smoke pot in to thinking that you want to call the cops on them.

    I guess if it makes you feel superior go ahead. But you just look like a jerk from this angle.

  • http://powerandcontrol.blogspot.com/ M. Simon

    I can tell you that contact with those drugs in my youth (a relative term) caused this highly suggestible hippie (look up “Hippies For McCain”) to become a Libertarian. Must a been the drugs.

    Actually if Tim Leary was right (most of psycology thinks so these days) Loughner had the wron Set and Setting. ‘S funny stace you seem to be hitting them in the septic tank these days.

  • http://powerandcontrol.blogspot.com/ M. Simon

    We have no idea of the strength of the alcohol he was drinking either. Was he a beer guy? A shot guy? Or a beer and a shot guy? You have to be careful with that stuff. Unlike pot it can kill you.

  • http://powerandcontrol.blogspot.com/ M. Simon

    Did you look at his videos? Classic schizophrenia. And you may be surprised to learn this but very few women find schizophrenics attractive.

  • http://powerandcontrol.blogspot.com/ M. Simon

    My evidence is anecdotal, but I have never seen a proper study of the possibility that the smoking of pot leads to schizophrenia.

    The TRUTH is out there. And you can use Google to find it.

  • http://powerandcontrol.blogspot.com/ M. Simon

    Pot? I don’t think so. I blame religion. Loughners’ mother was Jewish. So was Giffords. In fact they belonged to the same Reform Temple in Tuscon. You can look it up.

    QED.

  • http://peterreynolds.wordpress.com/ Peter Reynolds

    The NHS is a wonderful institution which highlights the differences between this mature civilisation and the stroppy adolescent that is the US.

    Peter Hitchens makes me ashamed to be British but it’s cancelled out by his courageous and inspirational brother, a long tiime mmj advocate

  • Djfblade1515

    and yet, there aren’t. Aside from this man, who used many more drugs than pot, when’s the last time anyone was raped, killed, or abused due to the use of marijuana? I’ll make it easy: no one.

    Number of people killed a year by drunk drivers: 185,000
    Number of people killed a year by stoned drivers: <10 (Look it up I swear!!!)

  • Anonymous

    Don’t take political advice from Britishers, either. The NHS has ruined them. Leftism is caused caused by a retrovirus endogenous to nationalized healthcare.

  • http://peterreynolds.wordpress.com/ Peter Reynolds

    Your brain is obviously overrun with low density lipids as well as your body. I’m a right wing, libertarian, eurosceptic Tory but that’s probably far too complicated for someone who betrays his Hicksville, hillbilly credentials so readily.

    You need to read it again:

    The NHS is a wonderful institution which highlights the differences between this mature civilisation and the stroppy adolescent that is the US.

  • http://peterreynolds.wordpress.com/ Peter Reynolds

    Having said that, I agree with everything you say apart from your ridiculous opinion of Britain. You really are behaving like a stroppy teenager kicking back against his Mum & Dad.

    When you grow up you’ll see things differently

Performance Optimization WordPress Plugins by W3 EDGE