The Other McCain

"One should either write ruthlessly what one believes to be the truth, or else shut up." — Arthur Koestler

Wisconsin Updates
HERMAN CAIN VIDEO ADDED

Posted on | February 19, 2011 | 147 Comments

Tea Party activists staged a “Stand With Scott Walker” rally today at the Capitol in Madison. Our man Troglopundit was on the scene and Tweeted that the union goons outnumbered the pro-Walker crowd. But he also Tweets this:

Speaker: Know when we got the idea for this rally? Thursday. Thousands of you here!

Given the short notice — I didn’t write about it until yesterday afternoon — the turnout seems pretty impressive: Instapundit has a crowd photo. He also has this video interview with Andrew Breitbart:

Lots more at The Lonely Conservative and Da Tech Guy points out that the union goons crossed the line with their Nazi analogies.

UPDATE: Blogs are way ahead of the regular news outfits on this story. Michelle Malkin:

Free-market champion and conservative businessman Herman Cain declares Madison “Ground Zero” in the battle against Big Labor.

That’s the first quote I’ve seen from Cain’s speech, and he spoke more than two hours ago. You would think that when a presidential candidate gave a speech at a major event like this, reporters on the scene would rush to be the first to report it. But you would be wrong. Anyway, Malkin is using reports via Twitter to cover the rally and posts this Twitpic of the scene:

UPDATE II: Jim Hoft is on the scene phoning in reports and sending photos via Lady Liberty. Meanwhile, the governor is standing tough and the Democrats are trying to back down:

Gov. Scott Walker on Saturday rejected an overture from a Democratic state senator that public employee unions had agreed to make financial sacrifices contained in the budget-repair bill in return for the right to bargain collectively.

So after all this protesting, now the unions want a “compromise”? Yeah, they’re losing this battle and they know it. John Fund at the Wall Street Journal explains why the Battle of Madison is so important.

UPDATE III: The New York Times reports from Madison, but evidently failed even to notice Herman Cain’s speech. Someone recently pointed out the blinding whiteness of the union protesters in Madison, but I’d hate to invoke that famous word with 5 A’s.

Meanwhile, from California, Joe Fein at Valley of the Shadow writes:

The protests by the Teacher unions (and the professional protesters called up by OFA and President Obama) in Madison, Wisconsin are almost a bad re-play of the Anti-war protests of the Bush years (both Bushes). Thus, deja vu.

UPDATE IV: Robert Costa of National Review got this video of Herman Cain’s speech:

Man, the people were cheering so loud they were drowning him out! (Nice fedora, BTW.)

UPDATE V: Welcome, Instapundit readers!

UPDATE VI: Welcome, Gay Patriot readers! And now Robert Costa has his report online at National Review.

UPDATE VII: Civility: No arrests reported at Tea Party protests. Just so we don’t forget what the protests are about:

Walker has called on 14 Democratic state senators, who fled the state rather than allow a quorum permitting a vote on the bill, to return to Madison.
Bill opponents say they won’t allow a vote unless Walker negotiates on the plan to eliminate collective bargaining rights for everything but wages. The legislation also would require most employees to pay more for their pensions and health insurance benefits.
“I have been informed that all state and local public employees — including teachers — have agreed to the financial aspects of Gov. Walker’s request,” said Sen. Jon Erpenbach, a Democrat. . . .
Walker, who says the state is “broke,” is asking legislators to pass his Budget Repair Bill to combat a $137 million shortfall through June 30. An upcoming two-year budget for 2011-13 must address a pending $3.6 billion deficit, he said.
The governor’s press secretary, Cullen Werwie, released a statement Saturday calling on Erpenbach, Senate Minority Leader Mark Miller and other Democrats to return from Illinois.
“These are many of the same senators who, two years ago, rammed through a billion dollar tax hike in 24 hours with no public input,” the statement said. “The quickest way to resolve the current situation is for the Democratic senators to stop shirking their responsibilities and debate the bill in Madison.”
Opponents say the proposed legislation is an attack on workers’ rights.

“Worker’s rights,” my ass! You’ve got no “right” to be employed by the state, nor any “right” to hold taxpayers hostage and demand that they give you more money or more benefits.

UPDATE VIII: Now a Memeorandum thread! I’m so happy I’m cuckoo for Cocoa Puffs!

UPDATE IX: Linked by Moe Lane — thanks!


Bookmark and Share

Comments

  • Anonymous

    OOOHHHH, such a rebuke! I am just amazed at your ability to argue.

    Can I choose an adjective for you too?

  • Anonymous

    My argument is not refuted by this? I asked a specific question: how does union busting solve the deficit and your response is to say “hah, it’s FUTURE union busting.” ‘Cause, really, Murph, did we think he had a time machine?

  • Anonymous

    Silence? No, I get long-winded ahistorical paranoid ramblings from old men; I get clever bon mots from morons; and I get union busting paranoia unseen since J Edgar Hoover was putting on a dress to protect conservative values, but I ask a serious question of the only informed commenter here and……..nothing.

  • Anonymous

    Silence? No, I get long-winded ahistorical paranoid ramblings from old men; I get clever bon mots from morons; and I get union busting paranoia unseen since J Edgar Hoover was putting on a dress to protect conservative values, but I ask a serious question of the only informed commenter here and……..nothing.

  • M. Smith

    I stand corrected: it was later than I thought.

    Still, I don’t think the unions can forever rest on those laurels.

  • M. Smith

    Re: “Silence?” (on a different subthread, but there’s no reply button where you said it):

    I turned off my computer to have fun with people who are in the same building as me. Sorry.

    You asked something about why collective bargaining needs to go to fix a budget surplus. I agree that there is no direct connection.

    Walker, who has spent a lot of time in local government trenches, says the local governments will need there to be no collective bargaining in order to balance their own budgets when he cuts the money the state gives them later this year. Or something like that.

    I’m not going to defend or attack Walker’s position on this at this time. In fact, I’m not going to get sucked in to this comment thread.

    I’ll say one more thing, however. The Dems frequently plot to destroy the GOP one way or another. For the GOP to attempt to do the same not surprising. The public sector unions are so much in control of the Dems that they are practically the same institution.

    Don’t worry, if either party ever does manage to deal a death blow to the other, a new party will spring up in its place.

    Now, if I don’t reply to any of your replies, assume it’s because I’m off having sex with a cute chick.

  • Anonymous

    Actually there never was a reason for the new Governor and legislature to negotiate after the Republicans won the majority and Governorship. I can’t say what the Unions were thinking, either they just couldn’t believe Republicans would win or they were counting on the Dem lame duck. That was a mistake as the “Lame Duck Dems”, to their credit, refused to p!ss on the will of the people. After Nov 2, the Republicans held all the cards, even the strike card is the Governor’s card if he remains resolute. The unions have lost big and the smarter among them know it. All the shrieking, wailing and rending of garments are merely mourning rituals. With any luck the other Republican run states will realize the time to strike is now while the iron is hot. It would be even luckier if the “Democrats Against Democracy” use the same tactics.

  • Anonymous

    IMHO the unions don’t have a legitimate claim to those laurels except to the extent that they have long “owned” the Democrats and set their priorities. That unions are responsible for Saturdays off and eight hour days is at least half “Union Mythology”.

  • Anonymous

    Too bad your corporate friends didn’t think so….working conditions in America at the end of 19th century commonly featured 12 hour workdays, 6-7 days a week and used kids too.

    Laws inspired by progressive reformers and unions helped change those laws, which were fought all the way to the Supreme Court by the sort of corporate fetishists one see at a Tea Party rally.

    Sad, you didn’t know this. Money doesn’t respect your religion

  • Anonymous

    Wikipedia is a the source for everything!

  • Anonymous

    Only 5 states do not have collective bargaining for educators and have deemed it illegal. Those states and their ranking on ACT/SAT scores are as follows:

    South Carolina – 50th
    North Carolina – 49th
    Georgia – 48th
    Texas – 47th
    Virginia – 44th

    If you are wondering, Wisconsin, with its collective bargaining for teachers, is ranked 2nd in the country.

    This isn’t to say that the lack of collective bargaining explains these poor outcomes, of course, but it is true that the evidence that breaking teacher’s unions improves educational outcomes is somewhere between “exceptionally weak” and “non-existent.”

    I’ll add how entertaining it is that the states with the lowest ACT/SAT averages also happen to be reliably GOP. I’m sure that’s a coincidence.

  • Tom in Michigan

    He didn’t say teachers, etc. were a blight; he said the public sector unions are – which is true. Ironically, public sector workers like police, fire, teachers will be the ultimate victims of the unions because a bankrupt government entity; state, municipal or federal will not be able to pay what’s been promised. Imagine a bankrupt company going on as if nothing had happened while promising to pay its employees. You’d have Enron, wouldn’t you. It’s the same with the good and decent people who have falled for the leftist lies put forth by the union bosses.

  • Chris

    Cain is able!!!! Cain 2012

  • Tom in Michigan

    What kind of silly analogy is this? Our Republic has survived a standing army quite well. In fact, the only army that was ever a threat to the nation was the Confederate Army. To your equally silly analogy below; though Reagan did indeed run a union, he also fired the PATCO workers when THEY went on an illegal strike.

  • Tom in Michigan

    What kind of silly analogy is this? Our Republic has survived a standing army quite well. In fact, the only army that was ever a threat to the nation was the Confederate Army. To your equally silly analogy below; though Reagan did indeed run a union, he also fired the PATCO workers when THEY went on an illegal strike.

  • Melody

    Who would have thunk!

    But then don’t you notice the bottom ranking states like SC, NC, GA and TX happen to have a disproportionate number of non-white minorities. Certainly the republican south doesn’t need a reason to empower the underprivileged dem base. Wisconsin is after all one of those more white states.

    First they came for the blacks, then they came for the gays, then they came for the unions, then they came for you.

  • Melody

    the bottom ranking states like SC, NC, GA and TX happen to have a disproportionate number of non-white minorities

    Just to clarify, that could be a reason for their low national

    Comparing the scores for NY and CA could give a better understanding of this phenomenon.

    And whether unions could have played a better role in improving the education levels of African Americans and also the over all standards (ie not hurting the whites at the expense of blacks), in states like SC, NC, GA, VA and TX.

  • Freedom

    Wow, I never in my life thought I would read such bass-ackwards rhetoric. You people need to read your history books. You wrongfully pull your tea party roots from the famous tea party in Boston. Leading individuals to think you have have some pro-democratic, free America base to your ideology. That movement was based on taxation without representation. Your movement appears to be based on legislation without representation. As ling as you get what you believe is right, there apparently can be no debate. All the ‘other side’ is asking for is some dialogue about WE can solve this crisis TOGETHER. You would rather polarize the issues, pit public versus private and tear this country apart. Shame on you for not knowing your history regrading this country or the fight for worker’s rights. Like weekends? Thank a union.

  • Teabaggersuck

    I live in Madison and was at the rally…you tea baggers had about 2k protesters while the pro-freedom movement had 60,000 protesters. Your party is a joke and you know it. You want to talk about racism? Your party consists of white affluent haves.

    Get a clue.

  • WorkersRights

    Thank you to your party for exposing itself for what it is, pro business, anti-freedom, ant-people. Your hatred for freedom is finally in full light.

    Screw us and we multiply. You will all be sidelined in the next elections!

  • Pingback: Quotes from Unions vs Taxpayer trenches at Bride of Rove

  • Ski3938

    If every union
    .in the country does not get behind the Wisconsin members all of them will lose their collective rights I did not see any marches in Washington or New York today if you do not act fast you will all lose every hard fought right The country going broke is the fault of the congress not acting not the union members.

  • Gmontpetit

    Why is main stream media afraid to introduce Herman Cain to us. It;s almost like they’re afraid of his very probable rum for president.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PEJFTJYMW32VYPAHYT6M5VHQCI Patricia

    I Congratulate WI. A line has been drawn in the sand. In America we have finally found our voices.
    We were silent or left in the dark about adding a second language to everything we use, or read in English speaking America.

    We were silent when others took the neighbors landscape, house cleaning, child care jobs even our teens summer or after school part time jobs.

    We were silent while our children’s classes become over crowded and it appeared they were not learning as quickly. Deliberately being held back to make our American education system fit all one Size.

    We held our noses or chose not to vote for someone who had ignored or betrayed us and found the new guy somewhat enchanting at times as he claimed he was for a United States of America. No color or political bent not welcome in his new house.

    Now we are seeing neighbor after neighbor, friend and family losing everything they had worked for. Too many all their life’s work gone in a flash.

    Many homeless, jobless and hopeless Americans our neighbors friends, family and many of us ourselves doubting we can make it to through the next few months let alone the next election.

    Seeing all that is happening around us here and throughout the world. Change is a coming. I do not know how it will end in Egypt.

    I do know they needed to do something in Tunisia which I believe so aptly reflects what is happening right here in America and right now.

    We have our entire country being held hostage by the most corrupt instigator in American history. Yes I do say that about the Elected President. He is yet again oberstepping what rights he was given by the electorate US.
    He seceded 80 miles of one of our soverighn states. Arizona and then sued it in an attempt to stop it from protecting the state including those 80 miles.
    That suit was joined by half of South America. Imagine in our life time seeing an elected official ever sue one of our States and joined by foreign countries.

    As I said the line has been drawn. We can never lose our voices ever again.

    Stand with Arizona, Stand with Wisconsin Stand up for America.

    I would suggest we offer this guy to do the right thing and resign. He wouldn’t, he does not have enough wit or class.

    Also his wife still has a few countries to visit while draining the Chinese treasury because it sure is not our money. What money we are on is borrowed, print on demand, paper.

    Silent majority no more.
    English only. Students get to school. Illegals get out while the going is easy. I do not think for one minute ANYONE in America wants to see or hear one iota of demands from you. Not now not anymore. Go and please close the door behind you.

    Obama and the national drain on our economy your wife. STOP you wife from any further free rides on our backs. We will not pay for protecting that fool for one instance it is not essecnetial.Period.
    Wait till you see the bill if you do not believe me.

    Your wife reminds me of giving debit cards affter a trgety. Vegas baby. Not food.. don’t let me go there. Spend like there is not limit or tommorrow.
    OVER .. Michelle is your problem don’t make her ours.
    It is over.
    Not only do most of us not care to be nice anymore. Talk about civility all you want. You sir are the Nations thug in chief, nothing more and if anything allot less.

    We Americans were basicly getting by and making do as we hoped to hold out to the end of your reign..

    You overstepped yet again. We turned the cheek and it does not work we see your cronies in the other direction.

    You, your good for nothing greedy FAT wife, your friends, the unions, the illegals, the early vote acorn types. It is over. I would start the packing because if you and your types are done.

    Or if you want to play.

    Games on!
    Gee and I am a 5′ 2″ mom to four.. I am infuriated beyond belief. I basically would have to say I detest you, your wife, I don’t even think your kids are cute anymore. Not while mine are doing without so much. They aren’t cute your kids that is, your Brazen attempt to appear greater than thou, wide bottomed wife, is making Brats out of them. You will not be able to afford or keep them in line We already see how you cannot keep your wife in line.

    Get your house in order.. pack up and go! You Sir, are no leader.
    You sir are the UN encapsulated.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PEJFTJYMW32VYPAHYT6M5VHQCI Patricia

    How does that fit with the 75 % illiterate rate of CA.. or is it just LA.. lala land

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PEJFTJYMW32VYPAHYT6M5VHQCI Patricia

    Tim.. are you self-employed.. care to offer who writes YOUR checks?

  • Anonymous

    Sadly all my corporate friends from the “late 19TH century have passed on.

  • Prime Director

    You know many people in the private sector signed employment contracts, too. Some of them lost their jobs because their employers could no longer profitably accomodate them; others were able to keep their jobs only because they renegotiated the terms of their employment and accepted a lower level of compensation.

    There is no reason public sector employees should be exempt from the same dynamic. Circumstances change. If you don’t like it, go get a job somewhere else; see if the high esteem in which you hold yourself is justified on the open market.

  • None

    most retarded $hit i ever had the displeasure of reading. congrats, you lose the internets.

  • SVT

    Hey, Mc Gehee – is this the same timmah that acted up at Protein Wisdom? He sures sound like it.

    Timmy – I picked “childish” because it’s an apt adjective for your “Nyah, nyah, nyah, nyah, nyah, nyah. I can’t hear you, I can’t hear you. I’m right, I’m right, I’m right cuz I say so, and Prime Director’s a poopy pants!” reply. If you don’t like the word childish, how about puerile, infantile, immature, or sophomoric?

    And Timmy thinks to himself, “I’ve got a great comeback. I’ll say, ‘Big deal. I can look up fancy words, too.’” in 3 ..2..1.

  • Anonymous

    The current NC legislature has Republican majorities in both houses for the first time since 1898 apparently the Democratic South doesn’t do a very good job empowering the underprivileged either.

  • Jim

    In case you were wondering you are awesome. I’m a UW student with a high school teacher for a father. I’ve been at the protests for the past five days. It seems like every time I talk to anyone who hasn’t been there they are missing the point. Thank you for understanding.

  • Pingback: Wisconsin Updates - includes Herman Cain and Andrew Breitbart

  • Anonymous

    The private sector partners whom I help make rich

  • Anonymous

    the same policemen and firefighters who supported the Govenor and whose unions are exempt? Like I said, union-busting of political opponents. Quit trying to make it sound high and mighty; it’s crass electioneering

  • Anonymous

    Yet the ideology you stole from them lives on

  • Anonymous

    I did not steal my ideology from anybody I was honored to receive it and was presented to me with full Robber Baron’s Honors.

    I remember it as if it was yesterday it was a nice spring day in 1898 on the grounds of the recently opened Biltmore. George Vanderbilt was, as always a very gracious host. It was a small simple ceremony only about 300 of the best sort attended, J. Pierpont Morgan, Jay Gould, Leland Stanford, and Andrew Carnegie. We were seated on exquisitely crafted lawn furniture made from a type of wood I didn’t recognize but which had silver dust worked into the surface by hand, producing a gleaming surface. We had discovered years ago that peasants made poor furniture. For entertainment there was a string quartet. During one of the breaks in the music I heard gunfire in the distance when I inquired as to the cause, Henry Frick assured me that it was nothing merely that some union organizers had been apprehended attempting come on the grounds and were being um….disciplined.

    Cornelius Vanderbilt made some brief remarks and the informal ceremony commenced James J. Hill presented me with my ideology and the brief ceremony ended. Having the correct ideology is crucial if one is properly exploit the masses which we all know is the key to good business as well as good governance.

  • Anonymous

    I did not steal my ideology from anybody I was honored to receive it and was presented to me with full Robber Baron’s Honors.

    I remember it as if it was yesterday it was a nice spring day in 1898 on the grounds of the recently opened Biltmore. George Vanderbilt was, as always a very gracious host. It was a small simple ceremony only about 300 of the best sort attended, J. Pierpont Morgan, Jay Gould, Leland Stanford, and Andrew Carnegie. We were seated on exquisitely crafted lawn furniture made from a type of wood I didn’t recognize but which had silver dust worked into the surface by hand, producing a gleaming surface. We had discovered years ago that peasants made poor furniture. For entertainment there was a string quartet. During one of the breaks in the music I heard gunfire in the distance when I inquired as to the cause, Henry Frick assured me that it was nothing merely that some union organizers had been apprehended attempting come on the grounds and were being um….disciplined.

    Cornelius Vanderbilt made some brief remarks and the informal ceremony commenced James J. Hill presented me with my ideology and the brief ceremony ended. Having the correct ideology is crucial if one is properly exploit the masses which we all know is the key to good business as well as good governance.

  • Anonymous

    yawn

  • Anonymous

    weird how you can’t seem to refute my points….

  • Anonymous

    Who isn’t a Commie to you, Bobby Welch? You see them on blogs, under your beds, protesting politically, taking the fries you serve them at work, driving by your mom’s trailer in their fancy cars. Where don’t YOU see “bolshes,” little John Birch?

  • Anonymous

    An ironic closing indeed for this blog and its proprietor.

  • Anonymous

    You should move there then. Maybe they have days where you can bash poor people in the street with a hammer for fun or shoot the ones who ask for a handout. Sounds like a perfect place for Ayn Randian doofus who thinks there are Commies hiding behind the tree in his yard

  • Anonymous

    Oh, they’re terrified. Wherever could one find a talk show dunce with a love for the plutocracy and a hatred of government regulation and taxes?

    Just send him your cash, Gmontpetit, ’cause I’m sure this “run” for the Presidency has nothing to do with separating morons from their checkbooks

  • Anonymous

    I think Nixon said it better when he was dividing the country, but it’s cool you haven’t forgotten whom to hate

  • Anonymous

    Never got around to reading the manual for that.

  • Anonymous

    Never got around to reading the manual for that.

Performance Optimization WordPress Plugins by W3 EDGE