The Other McCain

"One should either write ruthlessly what one believes to be the truth, or else shut up." — Arthur Koestler

They Don’t Pay Extra for Tears

Posted on | December 5, 2011 | 66 Comments

My 12-year-old son Jefferson with Herman Cain, July 17, 2011.

Journalism is a cynical racket and if you can’t dismiss tragedy and suffering with a sarcastic joke, you don’t belong in a newsroom.

Famine and wars, airplane crashes, disease, murder — horrible stuff happens to people every day, and your job is to turn it into that commodity called “news.” You’re not paid to give a damn about the human beings whose lives are blighted or destroyed by these disasters.

And most of the time, you don’t give a damn. Because you can’t, really.

You’d go nuts if you ever stopped to think — much less care — about the unspeakable misery involved in so much of what we call “news.”

Over the past several days, I’ve made a lot of phone calls and talked to a lot of people who joined me aboard that wild ride called the “Cain Train.” My thought was to write the definitive post-mortem on the campaign, to analyze this disaster based on all I’ve seen and heard over the past year. But I didn’t write that article, and there’s a reason why.

You see, it’s become a family tradition that, every year, Daddy takes his sons out to buy The Best Christmas Tree Ever. For all my personal and professional failures — “Not Good Enough for BlogCon” — I have an unbroken streak of success at doing this one thing. Every year, Daddy goes to get the tree and every year when I bring it home, the entire family agrees that this is The Best Christmas Tree Ever.

So about 7 p.m., instead of transcribing audio and doing that definitive analytical post-mortem on the Cain campaign I’d meant to write, my boys and I went off to find The Best Christmas Tree Ever. Of course, we succeeded, but while we were on our quest (with my 19-year-old son Bob at the wheel), I did manage to do a couple of interviews with my cell phone and handy digital recorder.

By the time we got back home, it was 9 o’clock — my wife said, “Wow! It really is The Best Christmas Tree Ever!” — and my American Spectator deadline was just three hours away. So I had to work fast and, after I started writing, the story took a detour that surprised even me:

Mike Rogers was on board what became known as the Cain Train even before the locomotive left the station. A computer systems engineer who lives in New Hampshire, Rogers first heard Herman Cain speak at an Americans for Prosperity conference in 2009, and immediately believed the Georgia businessman should be the next President of the United States. Rogers and his wife gave the maximum legal contribution to Cain’s presidential exploratory committee before the former Godfather’s Pizza CEO officially announced his Republican primary candidacy in May.
“I was sitting in the front row for the announcement in Atlanta,” Rogers said Sunday, a day after Cain returned home to Atlanta to announce that he would suspend his campaign, which had soared to the top of the GOP field in early October but was eventually derailed by accusations of sexual misconduct that the 65-year-old candidate has insisted are false and politically motivated. In announcing his exit from the campaign trail, Cain said he was moving from “Plan A” — winning the White House in 2012 — to “Plan B,” an issues-advocacy website, but Saturday was definitely the end of the dream that Rogers and thousands of other self-declared “Cainiacs” had dreamed for months.
“Plan B is just face-saving,” Rogers said. “Unless he’s able to clear his name and get back in, or clear his name and be picked as the [vice-presidential running mate] for somebody, essentially his best bet is to take his raised profile and get back on the radio, maybe a little bit of TV, and push his policies. But really, it’s not going to have the same force as being in the field shaping the debate.”
Unlike the TV talking heads, print pundits and late-night comedians who spent the past five weeks reporting, analyzing or mocking each new accusation against Cain, it’s not easy for true believers like Rogers to move on. The media immediately turned their attention to speculating about which of the remaining Republican candidates will benefit most from Cain’s painful encounter with the politics of personal destruction, while the dreamers awoke to life without a dream. . . . .

You really should read the whole thing. Some words you write with tears in your eyes, but they don’t pay extra for that. So I suppose I’ll be content with knowing I got The Best Christmas Tree Ever — again!



66 Responses to “They Don’t Pay Extra for Tears”

  1. Nancy Pelosi
    December 5th, 2011 @ 12:32 pm

    I like Barney Frank’s quote the best, where he said “I never thought I’d live such a good life that I would see Newt Gingrich be the nominee of the Republican party.”

    That quote I think spoke for a lot of us.

    One of these days we’ll have a conversation about Newt Gingrich.  I know a lot about him. I served on the investigative committee that investigated him, four of us locked in a room in an undisclosed location for a year. A thousand pages of his stuff.

  2. Nancy Pelosi
    December 5th, 2011 @ 12:33 pm

    I admit, I can’t resist the Donald. 

  3. Anonymous
    December 5th, 2011 @ 1:01 pm

    I think you may have hit the nail on the head there, Mikey. People forget that heroes define themselves by doing heroic stuff when the chips are down and it’s balls to the wall time.

  4. Steve in TN
    December 5th, 2011 @ 1:30 pm

    I’ve reached the point that I wouldn’t trust Ron Paul with my garbage.

  5. Bob Belvedere
    December 5th, 2011 @ 1:41 pm

    Jean Shepard’s A Christmas Story.

  6. Anonymous
    December 5th, 2011 @ 5:18 pm

    You know, most of the time when the news has an item like a murder trial of a high-profile L.A. Doctor, or perhaps a depressed Mom who drowned her kids, I just get sick of the “coverage.”

    All I want to know about those items is how it all worked out at the end.  Guilty? Behind bars? Insane?  I only want the one or two word answer, and then I’m through.  Like with O.J. I don’t want the lurid details about the stuff that happened in Vegas.  I just want to know if he went to jail.

    But with Cain, I want to know a lot more.  I invested some energy in trying to accept his bid.  I was always uneasy with his style, but I wanted a decent communicator with the right set of principles. Fortunately I’ve been through these things before, and I didn’t get too attached to his candidacy.  But I’m still torqued about the destruction.

    I want to know about all of the allegations, and I want to see some freaking lawsuits.  I want to know who screwed up the campaign, and whether the accusers were put up by some Chicago-style operative who paid them money. We need “discovery” and we need “depositions.”

    I want to see somebody’s ass in a sling for all of this grief, even if it ends up being Herman’s.

    And then I want to know the specific reason Palin chose not to run.  If some a**hole threatened her with exposure, I want to know who that person was.

    I want someone to start swinging back at this crap.  The problem is nobody is perfect enough to feel confident it’ll work.  So what we need is someone who’s willing to ride through it with a pirate-like attitude of justifiable non-perfection.  The old, “hey, I’m good, even if you don’t like how I conduct my private life.”

    We can’t win through this OWS mentality (everything is there to be shat upon) unless we get an attitude about it ourselves, and declare that hypocrisy is overrated.

  7. Monday-Catch-up:Too Much Going On! « Nice Deb
    December 5th, 2011 @ 5:21 pm

    […] also: RS McCain: They Don’t Pay Extra for Tears: All the pundits who low-rated Cain’s presidential prospects never seemed to see what Foley […]

  8. Anonymous
    December 5th, 2011 @ 5:23 pm

    That’s factually incorrect.

    The AUMF – Afghanistan and AUMF – Iraq both meet the Constitutional requirements for wartime operations.  That’s only two examples.

  9. Anonymous
    December 5th, 2011 @ 5:26 pm

    No.  Only the crappy candidates are gifted by the media with “low” negatives.

    High negatives ought to damn near be a prerequisite, anymore.

  10. In A Lonely Place « The Camp Of The Saints
    December 5th, 2011 @ 7:26 pm

    […] From Stacy’s post, published over at The Other McCain, which is much more personal: Over the past several days, I’ve made a lot of phone calls and talked to a lot of people who joined me aboard that wild ride called the “Cain Train.” My thought was to write the definitive post-mortem on the campaign, to analyze this disaster based on all I’ve seen and heard over the past year. But I didn’t write that article, and there’s a reason why. […]

  11. The Camp Of The Saints
    December 5th, 2011 @ 7:26 pm

    In A Lonely Place…

    We’ve all been there at one time or another, when someone we put our faith and trust in disappoints us deeply.  It bothers us even more when that person’s fall was aided in it’s tragic course by malevolent, outside forces. Such is the…

  12. Three Weeks From Today : The Other McCain
    December 5th, 2011 @ 11:54 pm

    […] Policy Polling – showed Herman Cain leading in Iowa by an average of 8 points.“Dreams Die Hard.”Plans change, and polls can’t predict the future.“People have asked me what I have […]

  13. Rbirchtree
    December 6th, 2011 @ 2:20 am

    K_Bob AUMF is not relavent to this discussion. If Ron Paul is elected to the presidency, and if Israel is indeed attacked, Congress can declare war to protect Israel.

  14. Anonymous
    December 6th, 2011 @ 6:20 am

    I didn’t bring up the erroneous statement about Congress having not declared war.

    I did disprove it. That’s the relevance.

  15. The Experience of Defeat
    December 7th, 2011 @ 10:11 am

    […] times I’ve mentioned that Stacy McCain was the first person I know who was on the Cain Train, and I think that was the case for a lot of people. After the way the political class has failed […]

  16. FMJRA 2.0: [Insert Appropriate Music Here] : The Other McCain
    December 10th, 2011 @ 3:01 pm

    […] EXPRESS SUNDAY: Complete Iowa Tour ScheduleRight Wing NewsHot AirKaty PunditRight Wing NewsHot AirThey Don’t Pay Extra for TearsNice DebThe Camp Of The SaintsFishersville MikeThe Camp Of The SaintsThe ConservatoryE-Mail to a […]