The Other McCain

"One should either write ruthlessly what one believes to be the truth, or else shut up." — Arthur Koestler

WATERLOO FOR BIRTHERS: Obama Releases Long-Form Birth Certificate

Posted on | April 27, 2011 | 42 Comments

UPDATE 12:10 p.m.: VIDEO: Obama Sermonizes About This Silly Distraction From His Incompetence

* * * * *

PREVIOUSLY (9:15 a.m. ET): The White House this morning released Barack Obama’s long-form birth certificate, which is now available online as a PDF.

UPDATE: CNN reports:

The White House released President Obama’s original birth certificate Wednesday.
The surprise release follows recent and sustained remarks by businessman Donald Trump, among others, that raised doubts as to whether the president was born in the United States.
White House spokesman Jay Carney is expected to speak more about the birth certificate Wednesday morning.

Wow. Guess their internal polls showed that Trump was really hurting their guy.

UPDATE II: Funny guys on Twitter:

UPDATE III: Associated Press:

White House spokesman Jay Carney says Obama felt the debate over his birthplace had become a “sideshow” that was bad for the country and political debate. . . .
“The president feels this was bad for the country, that it’s not healthy for our political debate,” Carney said.

Translation: “It wasn’t healthy for his re-election prospects.”

UPDATE IV: Ed Morrissey at Hot Air:

Note that the long form doesn’t have any mention of religion at all, which was one theory as to why Obama was supposedly “hiding” it, nor does it list anyone else as Obama’s father, another speculative bit of nonsense peddled by the birthers. The place of birth box is checked as within city or town limits, signed as thus by the attendant to the birth.
This conspiracy theory should have died three years ago. Now, maybe we can focus on all the ways Obama is failing as President.

Having dismissed the whole controversy as silly from the outset, and having mostly ignored it ever since, I was amazed at how much traction it got when Trump started pounding it in interview after interview.

UPDATE V: Professor William Jacobson had remarked on how much damage Trump was doing.

UPDATE VI: The Lonely Conservative:

I just have to wonder why they didn’t do this two years ago?

The White House press release is here and there is, as might be expected, a massive Memeorandum thread.

Next, I’m waiting for Andrew Sullivan to say, “See there? Now where’s Trig’s birth certificate? What’s Sarah Palin hiding?” In fact, Sully may have already said that, but I haven’t bothered to look yet.

UPDATE VII: Steve Eggleston:

In case you were wondering what it takes to get a copy of the original Certificate of Live Birth out of Hawaii, the White House provided the correspondence between Obama, his private lawyer, and Hawaii Director of Health Loretta J. Fuddy.

UPDATE VIII: You saw this coming, right?

“I’m taking great credit and you have to ask the president, ‘why didn’t he do this a long time ago? Why didn’t he do it a long time ago?’ When Hillary Clinton was asking, when everybody was asking, why didn’t he do it? It’s shocking. It’s shocking,” Donald Trump said at a press conference this morning on President Obama’s birth certificate.

Donald Trump: Not Just a Kook, an Effective Kook.

UPDATE IX: David Frum refers to Birtherism as “the racialist aspect of the anti-Obama movement,” which is rather a large leap. I always compared it to the various strange conspiracy theories about Mena Airport and/or Vince Foster that flourished during Bill Clinton’s first term.

In politics, some people are always more interested in throwing out spooky charges of criminality or fraud than in arguing over policy. You saw this during the Bush administration, with the stuff about Halliburton and Iraq, the claims of rigged voting machines in Ohio, the “Plamegate” controversy and all those wild fantasies about Karl Rove getting indicted.

UPDATE X: Linked by Pirate’s Cove and the Lonely Conservative — thanks! Our favorite Twitter celebrity weighs in:

That settles the question, doesn’t it? If it’s good enough for Alyssa Milano, there can be no further doubt!

UPDATE XI: Linked by Bob Belvedere at Camp of the Saints.


Bookmark and Share

Comments

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ric-Locke/100000452721401 Ric Locke

    At least Trump gets things done.

    Now for the college transcripts. Onward and upward!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=588368258 Lisa Graas

    I, for one, am relieved this was done now instead of waiting 3 weeks before the election.

    I see Obama birthers as having the same problem as Trig truthers: an unwillingness to accept legitimacy. It won’t go away for some of them because they weren’t in the room when Obama (or Trig) was born.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dan-Gillen/1366479171 Dan Gillen

    good enough for me. now can we see his transcripts from Harvard?

  • JeffS

    Say, what kind of font are they using on that birth certificate…..?

  • Anonymous

    So, is this the secret information that Trump was going to release. I’ve got a good idea: Let’s see his transcripts.

  • http://www.redstateeclectic.typepad.com AngelaTC

    And a previously unheard of self-proclaimed document expert will arise from nowhere and proclaim this to be a fake in 3…2…

  • Anonymous

    It’s not the Harvard Law transcripts you want. Everyone acknowledges that he aced that. It’s his undergraduate transcript at Columbia that would have interesting details.

  • Anonymous

    Well, unless that book coming out has anything better to show which isn’t super likely, that should be the end of it.

    I guess their strategy truly has become, “What more can he do for you people?!” the same as his idiotic true believers.

  • Anonymous

    The pdf looks like the certificate was faxed to the White House and they, in their ham-fisted way, decided to add the cross-hatch pattern behind it.
    As far as form and content (of the black portion), it looks right.

    I’m now more convinced that Obama was born in Hawaii than I am that OJ did it.

    On the other side of this … all those court cases costing how many millions of dollars. The man has no sense of the value of a dollar because it’s always somebody else’s dollar that he is spending.

  • http://www.redstateeclectic.typepad.com AngelaTC

    Now that you mention it, that’s it. While the GOP avoided the issue (presumably to keep from upsetting the liberals) Trump put it square in the middle of the table, and put Obama on the defensive.

  • JeffS

    Maybe…….(sotto voce)…….Charles Johnson?

  • Joe

    Did he release his college applications? Birthers must be sad.

    BTW, OT, but this has to be the most crazy raaaaacim evah: http://proteinwisdom.com/?p=27163

  • vtaguy

    Was African used as a race in 1961? Granted I was only 11 then but I thought it would have been Negro until after the late 60′s

  • Dan

    Why is Trump a “kook” for demanding answers?

    Since when is it sign of kookiness to want proof about the eligibility of politicians to hold certain elective offices, or are we just to take their word for it, ————- whatever the circumstances.

    Moreover, what exactly does this say about that jerk obama, who long ago could have laid this issue to rest, BUT INSTEAD, by his DELIBERATE, purposed passivity, gave incentive to the creation of this issue in the first place.

    THIS ISSUE EXISTS SOLELY BECAUSE of obama, his advisers, his staff, his wife.

    And no one else.

    And I want to see his bar applications, as well as his college applications and transcripts. I want to see it all.

  • Dan

    No, not “everyone acknowledges that he aced that.” When Obama graduated Harvard Law, 76% of those graduating received “with honors, {cum laude for our Latin scholars out there}. And as for “magna cum laude,” one need only have graduated in the top FIFTY PERCENT of the overall class.

    So what a fricken joke that “honor” system was!

    In fact, it was so bad, that not much after he graduated, Harvard Law changed their entire honor system.

  • Libertarian Advocate
  • Dan

    And another thing you’re forgetting is the role of grade inflation for those courses he took after his 1L and 2L required courses.

    Now what do you think the odds were of liberal profs at Harvard Law awarding top marks to their young, black male student?

    Now what do you think the odds of that were?

    That guy knows as much about getting top grades as he does about throwing a baseball like a red-blooded, American man!

  • America’s Guest

    Forget Trump, there’s probably something good in the new Corsi book, but now they can bray “Asked and answered! Asked and answered!” like Bill Clinton’s lawyers back in the day.

    I, for one, would very much like to hear how the man got into Pakistan in ’81 …

  • Pingback: Super Deep Thinker Obama To Release Birth Certificate Today (Now Released) » Pirate's Cove

  • Pingback: The Longest Running Clinton Scam Ends with Obama Releasing His Long-Form Birth Certificate | The Lonely Conservative

  • Brewdog

    This is from the White House news release on the birth certificate:

    “At a time of great consequence for this country – when we should be debating how we win the future, reduce our deficit, deal with high gas prices, and bring stability to the Middle East, Washington, DC, was once again distracted by a fake issue. The President’s hope is that with this step, we can move on to debating the bigger issues that matter to the American people and the future of the country.”

    First of all, that bitchy tone tells you all you need to know about whether Trump was gaining traction in the polls. They just couldn’t turn loose of the news release without giving us proles a good scolding for not sticking to the agenda.

    Second, who thought it was a good idea to list a bunch of issues for which Obama has abdicated all leadership? “We should be debating X, Y and Z” is so weak. It reflects Obama’s failure to lead. Note that in none of these cases has Obama put forward a specific plan. I guess that’s why he wants us to “debate,” to decide amongst ourselves what the right course of action is, and then Obama can get out in front and lead the parade after it starts down the street. Note that they say “we should be debating..” rather than “we should be focusing on.. ”

    A leader would have put out a statement that says: “Some people wanted to see my birth certificate. Here it is.”

  • http://thecampofthesaints.org Bob Belvedere

    One thing struck me about the birth certificate: you’ll notice that Barack Hussein Obama II was born at 7:24 P.M. on 04 August 1961

    So, he was born at night.

    How come it seems that he was born last night?

    Quoted from and Linked to at:
    Obama Releases His Long-Form Birth Certificate

  • Anonymous

    Enh. I don’t give a fig one way or the other, but 99+ percent of the media, and RS McCain, have gotten this wrong: this is a Certificate of Live Birth, not a birth certificate. The difference is important: a birth certificate tells where someone is born, a certificate of live birth means ‘here’s a baby that’s alive’ but does NOT establish where said baby was born.

    Obama could have been born on a spaceship orbiting a planet around Betelgeuse, shown up in Hawaii a couple weeks later, and gotten a Certificate of Live Birth.

  • http://proof-proofpositive.blogspot.com/ Proof

    It’s official: Junior was born in Hawaii. Wonder why he never uses the “II” when he writes out his full name? Maybe we can start a whole new movement: The Twothers?

  • Anonymous

    Why is Trump a “kook” for demanding answers?

    For the same reason that Sully is a kook for his “just askin’ questions” tactics on Trig Trutherism.

    There was never any reason to believe that Barack Obama was born anywhere other than Hawaii. Ergo, the presumed “constitutional” controversy over his eligibility was demonstrably idiotic. No previous president had been required to produce a birth certificate, so why now?

    As soon as Birtherism arose as a distinct phenomenon, I dismissed it as kooky — I’ll be glad to look up the links, if you wish — and I haven’t done a lot of posting against Birtherism for the simple reason that I never took it seriously. Furthermore, I was never one of those people who (like Frum, as quoted above) automatically interpreted Birthers as racists. But that is, in fact, how the elite always saw it and so, while I didn’t want to jump on the elite dogpile of finger-pointing, I just didn’t see any reason to pour any oxygen on these kooky flames.

  • Anonymous

    He waited too long to do it.
    However, IF (and I am not convinced until it has been checked by REAL Document Fraud experts. Obama and cronies have lied WAAAY too much for me to believe until it been verified) this is a good document, I am glad to see it.
    It proves Obama is not qualified because it shows that his father was not an American Citizen, and never was.
    NOW let’s see SCOTUS turn this down. It’s finally proof that needs clarification on WHAT a Natural Born Citizen is.
    We still have a long way to go, but thank you Trump!

  • Zachsteph

    you meant red-blooded American WHITE man – at least don’t be so circumspect – what were your grades at Harvard Law?

  • Pingback: VIDEO: Obama Sermonizes About This Silly Distraction From His Incompetence : The Other McCain

  • Dan

    What does white or black, or yellow for that matter have to do with being man enough to know how to throw a baseball, {and not throw a ball like a girl or some alternative type}.

    He threw like a flamer and the media covered that up for him too.

    Which directly is on point by the way, the point being that he’s not an American like the rest of us, regardless of the veracity of those documents presented.

    And as for my legal grades, —————— I passed the bar without even bothering to study for it.

  • Dan

    A} Prior Presidents needn’t have produced documentation because their pasts weren’t shrouded, DELIBERATELY, purposefully shrouded in mystery.

    B} You presumed bad faith on the part of your fellow citizens who at first had questions about his past, as if they were somehow obliged to accept his pronouncements upon such things at face value. No such obligation exists. Indeed, if any obligation exists, it rests with would be presidents to make available to their fellow citizens, to the electorate itself, such information that enables that electorate’s decision to be knowledgeable one. Obama by contrast preferred the electorate to be ignorant of him, his past, his associations.

    C} Prescinding from the political merits or demerits in pursuing the birth certificate line of attack, ———— as a general rule it must be maintained that eligibility requirements exist for a reason, and that politicians have a preexisting DUTY to present ALL SUCH documents prior to seeking or holding high office.

  • http://thecampofthesaints.org Bob Belvedere

    Hey…Dumb Ass: His mother is clearly listed as an American Citizen, which makes Barry a natural born one.

    Better to keep silent and be thought a fool….

  • http://ace.mu.nu/archives/279942.php Andrew Sullivan

    I am prepared, despite my hatred and fear of coochie, to plunge into Sarah Palin’s holy of holies, and prove I was right all along about Trig. I will take on Bristol too.

    And that is why I am the greatest individual blogger in the entire world. I am just that committed to my profession!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ric-Locke/100000452721401 Ric Locke

    Sorry, Bob, but that’s BS. So is RoBo, for that matter.

    Nationality or citizenship of the parents is irrelevant. A person born in the United States is a citizen of the United States, and of the State and City in which he resides.

    IF the parents are not U.S. citizens, under current law the individual may elect upon majority to be a citizen of the US or adopt his parents’ nationality. To accept citizenship in another country, they used to have to formally renounce American citizenship. Nowadays dual citizenship is permitted by law — but all that means is that the individual remains an American citizen.

    The issue continues to be “why the obsessive secrecy?” and a compliant Press full of AWOLers who demanded George W. Bush’s documentation back to the Flood, but insisted that we had to take Obama’s (and their) word for it without checking.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Ric-Locke/100000452721401 Ric Locke

    Sorry, Bob, but that’s BS. So is RoBo, for that matter.

    Nationality or citizenship of the parents is irrelevant. A person born in the United States is a citizen of the United States, and of the State and City in which he resides.

    IF the parents are not U.S. citizens, under current law the individual may elect upon majority to be a citizen of the US or adopt his parents’ nationality. To accept citizenship in another country, they used to have to formally renounce American citizenship. Nowadays dual citizenship is permitted by law — but all that means is that the individual remains an American citizen.

    The issue continues to be “why the obsessive secrecy?” and a compliant Press full of AWOLers who demanded George W. Bush’s documentation back to the Flood, but insisted that we had to take Obama’s (and their) word for it without checking.

  • http://thecampofthesaints.org Bob Belvedere

    I agree, Ric. In my haste, I did not add ‘His mother is clearly listed as
    an American Citizen and *he was born in the state of Hawaii’* – thanks for
    pointing out my wording error.

    I also agree with your last paragraph. Was it just to play games with us?
    What was the motivation? Sadly, a lot of people fell for this one of his
    cons, like so many more others fell for Barry’s big con.

  • Pingback: Obama to Address Birth Certificate at 9:45 AM | The Lonely Conservative

  • Pingback: Me? I’m A Competencer… « The Rhetorican

  • Pingback: Obama Releases Birth Certificate

  • Anonymous

    Yeah, because that’s a Constitutional requirement to hold office. You can read it, right there in….uh.

  • Pingback: Don’t Touch My Birth Certificate Junk : The Other McCain

  • Anonymous

    So when he went to school in Indonesia, and his name was Barry Soetoro, and he was registered as a muslim citizen of Indonesia, did his mom adoptive father commit fraud? If not, when did he become “unadopted”, when did he renounce his Indonesian citizenship and become a citizen solely of the Untied States and when did he legally change his name from Barry Soetoro to Barack Hussein Obama?

  • Kungqueror

    Is Donald Trump settled 0bama released? Just few minutes after White House announced it was released some graphic artists downloaded, imported to Adobe Illustrator, clicked “Object” then clicked “Show Hidden Layer.” the supposedly scanned document consists of three layers. If document was scanned to PDF it should be one layer, however, if it was manufactured using Adobe Photoshop or Illustrator then save as PDF it will show up when document imported to Illustrator. So what’s the verdict? Your superman is a fraud!

Performance Optimization WordPress Plugins by W3 EDGE