The Other McCain

"One should either write ruthlessly what one believes to be the truth, or else shut up." — Arthur Koestler

Did I Forget to Mention #RollTide?

Posted on | January 1, 2016 | 29 Comments

Alabama’s Tim Williams sacks Michigan State quarterback Connor Cook.

Thursday afternoon, my son Jefferson and I were watching #1 Clemson beat #4 Oklahoma in the Orange Bowl, and we began to discuss the upcoming Cotton Bowl game between #2 Alabama and #3 Michigan State. My father graduated at Tuscaloosa in the Class of 1951, and I was raised on ‘Bama football during the era when the Crimson Tide was coached by the immortal Bear Bryant. One of my earliest football memories is watching the Green Bay Packers in the famous 1967 “Ice Bowl” NFL championship game and. when Bart Starr scored the winning touchdown, my dad saying, “That’s Bart Starr! He’s a ‘Bama boy!” Then, of course, there was Joe Namath’s famous “guarantee” victory in Super Bowl III — another ‘Bama boy. Dad used to get tickets to the games, and I spent many Saturdays at Legion Field in Birmingham cheering the Tide.

Somehow, the ‘Bama games I attended that particularly stand out in memory are the defeats. In 1981, Georgia Tech beat us 24-21 — a real heartbreaker. Alabama and Tech used to be bitter rivals (mentioned in the ‘Bama fight song), but in the ’60s, Tech left the SEC and there was a 15-year interval before the rivalry was renewed. The 1981 game was a sellout and Dad couldn’t get tickets from ‘Bama, so we got them through our cousin Dan Post, a Tech alumnus. This meant we were seated in the middle of a bunch of Yellow Jacket fans, which made for an uncomfortable afternoon, especially because Robert Lavette ran all over us for two touchdowns. The other ‘Bama defeat that stands out in memory was the 1988 Hall of Fame Bowl in Tampa against Michigan. Dad got four tickets, so me, my two brothers and my brother’s wife went. Alabama fell behind 14-3 at halftime, and the Tide made a strong comeback , going ahead 24-21 on a Bobby Humphrey TD with less than four minutes left to play, but ended up losing 28-24. What I can never forget about that game was the Michigan fight song. It seemed like the Michigan band played that damned song every time their team so much as completed a pass. There is perhaps no experience in football more agonizing than to be playing Michigan, and losing, and having to hear their band blast out “Hail to the Victors” over and over and over.

Being born and bred ‘Bama, so to speak, I’ve raised my sons to be Crimson Tide fans, and shared with them the family lore. Dad used to say it was hard to be an Alabama fan because everybody wants to beat ‘Bama. There is never an easy week for Alabama, because every team on their schedule, no matter how lowly, is going to go all-out in hopes of upsetting the mighty Tide. Alabama has won 15 national championships and had 10 undefeated seasons, and expectations are always so high in Tuscaloosa that to lose even one game just ruins the whole year. Every Saturday, the Tide takes the field against an opponent totally fired up and dreaming of an upset, and this year ‘Bama lost to Ole Miss 43-37 in a game marred by five turnovers. It was an agonizing game for a Tide fan to watch and, because Ole Miss is an SEC West opponent, the consequences of that defeat were potentially devastating for Alabama’s hopes of a conference championship. That loss meant that, in order for the Crimson Tide to make it to the SEC title game, they would have to win the rest of their conference games and Ole Miss would have to lose twice to SEC opponents. And what were the odds of that?

Well, miracles happened. Ole Miss lost to Florida 38-10, and then in November, they lost a wild 53-52 overtime game to Arkansas, the same day Alabama beat LSU 30-16. What had seemed impossible just six weeks earlier had become a reality — Alabama controlled its own destiny, with a shot at the SEC title and, perhaps, even the National Championship. Ranked as low as #13 after the loss to Ole Miss, the Crimson Tide rose to #4 after beating LSU. Finishing the regular season strong with a 29-13 win over Auburn, and beating Florida 29-15 in the SEC Championship game, the Crimson Tide then saw junior running back Derrick Henry win the Heisman Trophy, and faced Michigan State in the BCS semifinal on New Year’s Eve.

So there we were Thursday afternoon in the McCain family living room, watching Clemson play Oklahoma. I was on the sofa, holding my 4-month-old grandson Alexander,. My 17-year-old son Jefferson was cuddled up on the love seat with his girlfriend Jade, and we started talking about a Clemson-Alabama matchup for the national title.

“Well, Michigan State’s gonna be tough,” I said, mentioning that the Spartans had defeated Ohio State, last year’s national champion.

To this my son replied, quite astutely, that Coach Nick Saban is college football’s most cunning analyst of game videos and he had had three weeks to watch video of Michigan State.

“True — if they’ve got a weakness, Saban will find it,” I said, but with memories of that error-plagued Ole Miss game haunting me, I added, “Bama has got to execute. No fumbles, no dropped passes, no missed tackles, no penalties.”

Clemson had trailed Oklahoma 17-16 at halftime, but in the second half, the Tigers took control, winning decisively 37-17. Watching this impressive performance by the undefeated No. 1 team, I said to Jefferson, “Clemson’s tough, but I think ‘Bama matches up pretty good with them, if we can just win tonight. What would be good, though” — and here I expressed a fond hope — “is if we can just dominate Michigan State. Beat the hell out of them and send a message to Clemson.”


Alabama’s Jake Coker had his best game ever Thursday.

What was brilliant was that Saban, knowing how Michigan State would be set up to stop Derrick Henry, had Jake Coker use play-action passes to pick apart the Spartans’ secondary. Coker was 25 for 30, throwing for 286 yards and two touchdowns. Even though Michigan State held Henry to under 100 yards, he still scored two touchdowns. While the Crimson Tide racked up more than 400 yards of total offense, however, it was Alabama’s defense that was most impressive, holding Michigan State to only 29 rushing yards, and ‘Bama absolutely humiliated the Spartans’ quarterback. As ESPN’s Ivan Maisel said, the Tide defense “sacked Michigan State quarterback Connor Cook four times, intercepted him twice, and never gave him a chance to breathe.” The crucial play of the game came late in the first half. The Tide had taken a 10-0 lead, but Cook took the Spartans down to the ‘Bama 12 yard-line. A touchdown, or even a field goal, would have given Michigan State a boost in morale before halftime, but with 15 seconds left, Alabama’s Cyrus Jones intercepted Cook’s pass, and that seemed to destroy whatever hope the Spartans had left. Jones, incidentally, added a 57-yard punt return for a touchdown in the second half, a bit of icing on the cake of exactly what I had hoped for — a totally dominating Alabama performance. With their shutout of Michigan State, the Crimson Tide sent a clear message to Clemson: “Watch out. We’re coming to beat you.”

Alabama’s Cyrus Jones returns a punt for a touchdown.

Can Alabama do it? Of course they can, if they execute, concentrate, and avoid mistakes. Mental focus is the difference between giving up 43 points to Ole Miss and shutting out Michigan State. Championship football isn’t just about strength and speed — every man on the field is strong and fast — it’s about execution. What causes defeat is fumbles, dropped passes and missed tackles. Throwing an interception is bad, but you just factor that into the risks of the passing game. You throw enough passes, you’re gonna get intercepted every so often, but there is no excuse for a fumble. My father used to erupt in rage — “He was carrying the ball like a loaf of bread!” — whenever an Alabama player would fumble, and a dropped pass would always make Dad cuss. He played end in high school, and he had a zero-tolerance attitude toward dropped passes. “If you can get your hand on the ball, you ought to catch it,” was the sum total of his view on the subject. Likewise, Dad couldn’t stand to see a missed tackle. Proper tackling technique is just basic football, and for a player on scholarship at the University of Alabama to fail at such a basic task — well, this was simply unacceptable.

All the strength, speed and talent in the world won’t win a football game if players make those kind of mistakes, which are the result of mental lapses, a failure to concentrate. At the highest level of competition, the winning team is the one that avoids mistakes, and takes advantage of the opponent’s mistakes. You can get away with sloppy plays against a weak team (and honestly, Alabama got away with a few mistakes against Michigan State) but championship football requires nearly perfect execution, play after play. Watching Clemson beat Oklahoma, it was easy to see why the Tigers are undefeated. If the Crimson Tide doesn’t play their very best game Jan. 11 against Clemson . . .

Well, I prefer not to think about that possibility. Instead I hope Alabama gives an all-out effort from the opening kickoff to the last whistle. If they play their best, the Crimson Tide can beat anybody, and that probably explains why I always remember the games that ‘Bama lost.

They lose so rarely, after all.



  • Finrod Felagund

    Congratulations to Alabama for making the title game. By the way, the rest of the Big Ten hates Michigan and their fight song as well; this is all I remember of the rather dirty parody of their fight song:

    “Hail to the fornicators, hail to the masturbators / Hail, hail, to Michigan, the scourge of the West”

  • Evi L. Bloggerlady


  • robertstacymccain

    Well, it’s a catchy tune, but you never want to hear it when your team is playing Michigan. That day in Tampa, I tell you, they played it over and over. I’d almost rather hear “War Eagle,” which is the most evil song in the history of music.

  • Finrod Felagund

    I’ve been told that there are fairly obscene parodies of all the Big Ten schools’ fight songs, but that was also back when there were only 10 teams in the Big Ten. The only other one I’ve heard even part of is for IU: “We will fight for our cream and sugar, and our coffee, every day”

  • M. Thompson

    So, Bear Bryant fedoras via Amazon for this one?

    Shameless capitalist blogging strikes again. 😉

    Of course the hapless Gophers somehow won the meaningless QuickLane Bowl in Detroit this year…

  • Mike G.

    I know the long standing rule about support for ‘Bama, but as for me, I’m going for the Clemson Tigers!

    Sorry buddy. 😉

  • marcus tullius cicero

    …Alabama is #1……

  • WarEagle82

    I hate to see ‘Bama win but I don’t think a non-SEC team is going to be ‘Bama and I don’t think the Clemson Tigers have it in them. I looked at the Clemson Tigers’ schedule and it didn’t really impress me as a particularly strong schedule.

    And just for Stacy:

    War Eagle! See you at the Iron Bowl next year!

  • Nan

    Yeah, but who wanted to go to Detroit?

  • joethefatman

    I really miss being in Birmingham at the US Steel plant when Bama would win. I never really cared one way or another about the team, it was just fun watching them celebrate.

  • M. Thompson

    Exactly. NCAA bowl games are a dime a dozen.

  • GruntOfMonteCristo


  • Finrod Felagund

    There are so many bowl games nowadays they had to let some 5-7 teams play in bowls because not enough teams had 6 wins.

  • robertstacymccain

    Well, the way Clemson beat Oklahoma was impressive, as I say, and I can’t imagine Alabama would be underestimating Clemson.

    Personally, I’ve always felt that establishing the running game is Basic Football 101. If you can make the other team respect your running game, this opens up the passing game, but if you are consistently moving the ball on the ground, why bother throwing the ball at all? Well, the real reason is this: If a college team doesn’t have a good passing game, they’re going to have a tough job recruiting quarterbacks and receivers. So what would be smart strategy — Basic Football 101, the old Bud Wilkinson 3-yards-and-a-cloud-of-dust offense — gets put aside in favor of the riskier pass-oriented offense AND I DON’T LIKE IT.

    All of that is by way of saying that if I had my druthers, Alabama’s game plan against Clemson would be Derrick Henry right, Derrick Henry left, Derrick Henry up the middle. Just pound away at the Clemson defense, play after play, until they finally break down. I think Alabama could win that kind of test of strength, if their defense can hold Clemson off the scoreboard and maybe intercept Watson a time or two in the first half.

    I don’t know what Saban will do, but I know what I would do — establish the running game, make Clemson defend against the run, and don’t bother with the passing game unless Clemson scores first. Defense wins football games. That shutout against Michigan State demonstrated the strength of Alabama’s defense, and if they play that well against Clemson, I think Alabama wins no matter what Saban does on offense. Just execute.

  • Fail Burton

    Tide’s on a roll. They’ve failed to score at least 27 pts. only once the entire season and given up more than 17 only twice. That spells trouble for Clemson. By my reckoning Clem is more like a legitimate 10-3 team but Ala equal to their record. I say Ala by 7.

  • Christine Bedford

    ?my neighbor’s stride mother is making 98$ HOURLY on the internet?….

    A few days ago new McLaren F1 subsequent after earning 18,512$,,,this was my previous month’s paycheck ,and-a little over, 17k$ Last month ..3-5 h/r of work a day ..with extra open doors & weekly paychecks.. it’s realy the easiest work I have ever Do.. I Joined This 7 months ago and now making over 87$, p/h.Learn More right Here
    ??? http://GlobalSuperEmploymentVacanciesReports7even/GetPaid/98$hourly?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?

  • Evi L. Bloggerlady

    They didn’t hear it.

  • Unix-Jedi

    Might be a running battle on both sides.

    If Clemson’s offensive line can open any hole, Gallman is incredibly dangerous, and Watson’s scrambling could be disruptive.

  • Unix-Jedi

    When they Clemsoned so hard they Clemsoned their Clemsoning with Notre Dame – the team really seemed to have turned a corner.

  • Unix-Jedi

    Words? To a fight song?

    See, this is why I’m partial to the ones that stick to the tune. Like, say..

  • robertstacymccain

    The “line” on any championship football game is always deceptive. Most Super Bowls are blowouts. Why? Because the team that falls behind by more than a touchdown is under pressure, and usually is forced to pass more than run. Passing when the other team expects the pass almost always means more sacks and more interceptions. Whether the defense goes “nickel” (with an extra safety and thus more coverage) or blitz (bringing a linebacker to rush the quarterback), the advantage shifts to the defense whenever a team is forced to pass. So when a team falls behind by 10 or 14 points, the odds are they will lose by an even wider margin — 17, 21 or more. To say “Alabama by 7” doesn’t mean much, really, because if they win by one touchdown, they’re like to win by at least 10.

  • Fail Burton

    I predicted Holm over Rousey, McGregor over Aldo. Alabama by 7.

    And Carlos Condit over Lawlor tonight.

  • badanov

    Well, Bless your heart, RSM 🙂

    Seriously though every year since about 2007 I have made it a point of watching Alabama’s first game to see how good their defense is. That’s how I gauge how good they’ll be.

    So, I guess I am an Alabama fan, though not as much as youand your family is.

    Anyway, Roll TIde.

  • trangbang68

    I’m Auburn to the bone but I have to give the Tide props. That defense is off the charts.

  • trangbang68

    War Eagle, buddy!

  • FLBuckeye

    I hate TTUN, as scUM is referred to by Buckeye fans. Since 2001 we are 13-2 against TTUN.
    Oh, and btw, we beat Bama last year. Was at the Fiesta bowl yesterday and enjoyed beating the Domers
    I expect Bama to DESTROY Clemson

  • maryqalbritton

    ?my neighbor’s stride mother is making 98$ HOURLY on the internet?….

    A few days ago new McLaren F1 subsequent after earning 18,512$,,,this was my previous month’s paycheck ,and-a little over, 17k$ Last month ..3-5 h/r of work a day ..with extra open doors & weekly paychecks.. it’s realy the easiest work I have ever Do.. I Joined This 7 months ago and now making over 87$, p/h.Learn More right Here
    ??? http://GlobalSuperEmploymentVacanciesReportsDeko/GetPaid/98$hourly?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?.?

  • Pingback: Jax State Is #FCSCocky Today #FearTheBeak! #BlowSoutherners UPDATE: Bisons Defeat JSU 37-10 as NDSU Claims Fifth Straight Title : The Other McCain()

  • Pingback: #RollTide: Alabama Crimson Tide Faces Clemson for National Title : The Other McCain()