by Smitty

Via somebody on Twitter, sorry:
Some people can, to an eerie degree. A study from earlier this summer found that college students had “above-chance accuracy” when guessing whether people were straight or gay, even when they were shown faces without any contextual clues. Even when they only got to look for 50 milliseconds. Even when the faces were upside-down.
For those primed to detect sexual orientation (one author speculated that older people or those from other cultures might have a harder time), it would seem that facial features can be a semi-reliable indicator of sexual orientation.
I think it is called Gaydar.
Indeed.
I am able to tell that Rip Taylor, Charles Nelson Reilly, and Andrew Sullivan are gay. I am that good!
Uhm, so?
If I were participating in an unbiassed survey wherein I was presented one hundred pictures of the faces of randomly chosen people, I could just answer “straight” each time and be correct in 95% of cases.
I subscribe to the position that everyone is GAY.
Now GET OFF MY LAWN!
And I’m sure these scientists presented a general population-appropriate mix of faces, right?
But…P-Values! You have to follow the the links to get any sense of the statistics, like:
While I’m sure they were able to get their p-values below the magic value of 0.05, those numbers aren’t very impressive. Certainly worse than your scenario.
So, all this means is that people can recognize a butch cut. Duh!
On the men it may be the mascara. Not sure about that one.
I used to have a great Gaydar, having been in the music business during the Punk/New Wave yesrs, but not anymore. I think this is due to the feminization of male appearence.