CBO Performs Voodoo Math and Other Undead Zombie Health Care Updates; UPDATE: ‘Does the CBO’s Shady Accounting Trick Make My Butt Look Big?’ UPDATE II: Ramming Speed! ‘Slaughter Solution’ Passes 222-203

Posted on | March 18, 2010 | 28 Comments

UPDATE 3:56 p.m. ET: Michelle Malkin has the details on the procedural vote whereby the House Democrats approved the so-called “Slaughter Solution” to allow them to pass the Senate version without actually voting on it. This is a Constitution-be-damned-just-ram-it-through move, and Michelle links this fretful remark from AOSHQ:

“I am getting really worried, because if 222 Democrats voted for this unconstitutional, very-unpopular maneuver, doesn’t that mean that all 222 will also vote for the bill itself? Why vote for this if you’re not going to vote for that?”

Yeah, we’re teetering on the brink here. Yet there is strange optimism (!) from Allahpundit:

Altmire dumped on the Slaughter strategy before voting for it. So did Stephen Lynch — who, interestingly, said he was a no on the bill itself just a few hours ago. My hunch is that they both want to vote no on O-Care but don’t want to be blamed for tying Pelosi’s hands in case she’s able to get to 216 by using Slaughter, so they’re throwing the leadership a bone on this vote.

This charade is so twisted and bizarre, it’s impossible to calculate the odds. I think the undecided Democrats have been so relentlessly arm-twisted by Rahm and Nancy that they’re like suspects who, under extraordinary police interrogration, confess to crimes they didn’t commit.

UPDATE 2:30 p.m. ET: Jacob Sullum at Reason‘s Hit & Run:

The Medicare savings, which may not actually materialize because they depend on reimbursement changes Congress has been loath to maintain in the past, total nearly $500 billion during the first decade, compared to total deficit reduction of $130 billion. . . .
CBO warns that it “does not generally provide cost estimates beyond the 10-year budget projection period” and that its projections for the second decade are subject to “an even greater degree of uncertainty” than its projections for the first 10 years. . . . Yet the Democrats have transformed these highly uncertain projections into a seemingly precise and reliable dollar figure: $1.2 trillion in deficit reduction during the second decade.

Philip Klein at The American Spectator:

What basically happened is that Democrats were rushing to get out the CBO scores so that they could have some sort of claim to have released them 72 hours prior to a vote, which they want to hold on Sunday. But we won’t have 72 hours to look at the actual final scores.

Phil provides this graphic illustrating the Democrats’ clever accounting trick:

It’s like a fat chick wearing a black skirt because she thinks it makes her look skinny. The Lonely Conservative dubs it the “ObamaCare Layaway Plan.” More blog commentary from Gateway Pundit, Nice Deb, The New Editor, Confederate Yankee, Le·gal In·sur·rec· tion, IMAO, Sister Toldjah and Weasel Zippers.

PREVIOUSLY: As of 1 p.m., the official Congressional Budget Office estimate of ObamaCare’s budget is overloaded by traffic, but don’t worry: The rectal extraction accounting process is sufficiently transparent that Ed at Hot Air and Steve at No Runny Eggs can read it:

CBO and JCT previously estimated that enacting H.R. 3590 by itself would yield a net reduction in federal deficits of $118 billion over the 2010-2019 period, of which about $65 billion would be on-budget. . . . That incremental effect is an estimated net reduction in federal deficits of $20 billion over the 2010-2019 period over and above the savings from enacting H.R. 3590 by itself; almost all of that reduction would be on-budget.

Translation: We’ve cooked the books with a shamelessness that would make Enron blush!

Steny Hoyer is happier than a shoplifter who just found out the security camera system is out of order.

UPDATE: Whatever you do, don’t call Doug Elmendorf at the CBO and say, “Hey, this is Bernie Madoff — great work you’re doing there!”

UPDATE II: Drew M at AOSHQ:

I’m not going to pretend to be a budget wonk but aside from the fact that the CBO projections are based on the ‘facts’ provided to them by Democratic leadership, the Director of the CBO says this isn’t a real estimate . . .
The question is, will enough Democrats who claim to worry about the deficits drink this Kool-Aid and consider this a sufficient fig leaf to go over the cliff with Nancy? I fear the answer is yes.

Again, I implore readers: Please do not make prank phone calls to CBO at (202) 226-2700.

UPDATE III: Daniel Foster quotes this from the CBO report:

Although CBO completed a preliminary review of legislative language prior to its release, the agency has not thoroughly examined the reconciliation proposal to verify its consistency with the previous draft. This estimate is therefore preliminary, pending a review of the language of the reconciliation proposal, as well as further review and refinement of the budgetary projections.

(Hat-tip: Instapundit.) Basically, the CBO has been assigned to evaluate a proposal that was plastic as Play-Do, with the legislative ingredients re-jiggered until Elmendorf’s crew could give them the budget estimate they wanted. Twitter buddy Greg Howard:

DID AL GORE & EAST ANGLIA DO THE CBO NUMBERS?

Yeah, so no fair calling Doug Elmendorf, faking a British accent and telling him you’re from the Climate Research Unit and want to hire him to do his mathematical magic on the global-warming numbers.

PREVIOUSLY:

Category: Barack Obama, Congress, Health Care, Uncategorized

Comments

28 Responses to “CBO Performs Voodoo Math and Other Undead Zombie Health Care Updates; UPDATE: ‘Does the CBO’s Shady Accounting Trick Make My Butt Look Big?’ UPDATE II: Ramming Speed! ‘Slaughter Solution’ Passes 222-203”

smitty
March 18th, 2010 @ 5:27 pm

“shoplifter who just found out the security camera system is out of order”

Hey hey hey: let’s not get personal here, shall we?
smitty
March 18th, 2010 @ 12:27 pm

“shoplifter who just found out the security camera system is out of order”

Hey hey hey: let’s not get personal here, shall we?
Al in St. Lou
March 18th, 2010 @ 5:39 pm

This is as bad a lie as that NIE that said Iran had totally stopped working on nukes. That’s two instances of supposedly nonpartisan pieces of the federal government enabling Dem wishes to come true. I’m sick of it.
Al in St. Lou
March 18th, 2010 @ 12:39 pm

This is as bad a lie as that NIE that said Iran had totally stopped working on nukes. That’s two instances of supposedly nonpartisan pieces of the federal government enabling Dem wishes to come true. I’m sick of it.
Roxeanne de Luca
March 18th, 2010 @ 6:43 pm

Best line I heard about this “universal health care will reduce the deficit” nonsense was something to the effect of “It’s too bad we don’t have 60 million uninsured people, so we could save twice as much money.”
Roxeanne de Luca
March 18th, 2010 @ 1:43 pm

Best line I heard about this “universal health care will reduce the deficit” nonsense was something to the effect of “It’s too bad we don’t have 60 million uninsured people, so we could save twice as much money.”
The ObamaCare Lay Away Plan | The Lonely Conservative
March 18th, 2010 @ 2:08 pm

[…] Stacy McCain says it’s like a fat chick wearing a black skirt because she thinks it makes her butt look skinnier. I don’t know, I think she might want to invest in Spanx®. […]
Sherry
March 18th, 2010 @ 7:13 pm

Using this same logic, if we ensure the entire nation, we could eliminate the debt entirely.
Sherry
March 18th, 2010 @ 2:13 pm

Using this same logic, if we ensure the entire nation, we could eliminate the debt entirely.
The St. Angilbert Press » The REAL Hockey Stick Graph!
March 18th, 2010 @ 3:37 pm

[…] Stacy McCain displays a graphic from Phil Klein at AmSpec concerning the long-term projected costs of the health care reform being […]
Lonely Conservative
March 18th, 2010 @ 9:00 pm

The only thing keeping me from losing my lunch right now is the FMJRAA. Thanks.
Lonely Conservative
March 18th, 2010 @ 4:00 pm

The only thing keeping me from losing my lunch right now is the FMJRAA. Thanks.
Joe
March 18th, 2010 @ 9:04 pm

Sdferr made the following comment over at PW which I believe is a valid distinction:

Comment by sdferr on 3/18 @ 2:45 pm #

“They passed the Slaughter Rule…” is not a little indistinct Joe.

What they passed was on the question “whether the Slaughter Rule could be used” as a tactic (which is alarming in itself, as you say), as opposed to passing the Slaughter Rule itself, which, if it will be done, will be done later in the weekend or after.

In any case, clarity in these matters counts, I think.

The ice may be cracking but the break up has not happened yet.
Joe
March 18th, 2010 @ 4:04 pm

Sdferr made the following comment over at PW which I believe is a valid distinction:

Comment by sdferr on 3/18 @ 2:45 pm #

“They passed the Slaughter Rule…” is not a little indistinct Joe.

What they passed was on the question “whether the Slaughter Rule could be used” as a tactic (which is alarming in itself, as you say), as opposed to passing the Slaughter Rule itself, which, if it will be done, will be done later in the weekend or after.

In any case, clarity in these matters counts, I think.

The ice may be cracking but the break up has not happened yet.
Bring on the Law Suits | The Lonely Conservative
March 18th, 2010 @ 4:14 pm

[…] The Other McCain AKPC_IDS += "17887,";Popularity: unranked [?]Possibly Related PostsMarch 17, 2010 — Mark Levin […]
Since I will be out tonight………. « The Daley Gator
March 18th, 2010 @ 4:20 pm

[…] The Other McCain […]
Dems Vote For Slaughter, Against Our Constitution » Pirate's Cove
March 18th, 2010 @ 4:23 pm

[…] and regarding the CBO scoring of ObacistCare, R.S. McCain writes: It’s like a fat chick wearing a black skirt because she thinks it makes her look skinny. […]
pivey
March 18th, 2010 @ 9:59 pm

Just called through the code red list- got to the O’s. The worst part was getting through to Bart Gordon’s office and the man telling me he wouldn’t be surprised if he voted for it. I asked if he was going to get that cushy NASA job & he said he didn’t know anything about that. Upon hearing he’d vote for it, I got a little unhinged – I grew up in his district & when I turned 18, I went to my first Boot Bart meeting. I started saying ‘How does he sleep at night?’ ‘Doesn’t he know that he represents Tennessee?’ You know, the home of Davy Crockett and Andrew “One man with courage makes a majority” Jackson. The man had to calm me down and move on to the next person.

I know one thing for sure, Bart better not set foot in Tennessee ever again, not even to take his little girl to Dollywood.
pivey
March 18th, 2010 @ 4:59 pm

Just called through the code red list- got to the O’s. The worst part was getting through to Bart Gordon’s office and the man telling me he wouldn’t be surprised if he voted for it. I asked if he was going to get that cushy NASA job & he said he didn’t know anything about that. Upon hearing he’d vote for it, I got a little unhinged – I grew up in his district & when I turned 18, I went to my first Boot Bart meeting. I started saying ‘How does he sleep at night?’ ‘Doesn’t he know that he represents Tennessee?’ You know, the home of Davy Crockett and Andrew “One man with courage makes a majority” Jackson. The man had to calm me down and move on to the next person.

I know one thing for sure, Bart better not set foot in Tennessee ever again, not even to take his little girl to Dollywood.
pivey
March 18th, 2010 @ 10:00 pm

Just saw that Fess Parker died today – how fitting in light of my last comment.
pivey
March 18th, 2010 @ 5:00 pm

Just saw that Fess Parker died today – how fitting in light of my last comment.
dad29
March 18th, 2010 @ 11:27 pm

“Hello, CBO?? I have a tax return I’d like you to work on for me….”
dad29
March 18th, 2010 @ 6:27 pm

“Hello, CBO?? I have a tax return I’d like you to work on for me….”
Bob Belvedere
March 19th, 2010 @ 1:17 am

Great job, Stacy – thank you.

Linked to at:
At The Precipice
—–
It’s Time To ROC ‘N’ ROLL:
Restore Our Constitution & Restore Our Lost Liberties
Bob Belvedere
March 18th, 2010 @ 8:17 pm

Great job, Stacy – thank you.

Linked to at:
At The Precipice
—–
It’s Time To ROC ‘N’ ROLL:
Restore Our Constitution & Restore Our Lost Liberties
Decisions, Decisions, Decisions « Just Above Sunset
March 19th, 2010 @ 3:01 am

[…] But never mind, there’s Robert Stacy McCain: […]
Of Course The Democrats Wouldn’t Lie About A Memo About CBO ‘Estimate’ : The Other McCain
March 19th, 2010 @ 5:28 pm

[…] About CBO ‘Estimate’RAMMING SPEED! Democrats Prepare for ‘Really Stupid and Futile Gesture’CBO Performs Voodoo Math and Other Undead Zombie Health Care UpdatesDennis Kucinich to Vote ‘Yes’ and Other Updates on Zombie Health Care Bill Undead Zombie Health […]
CODE RED! D.C. Rally NOON TODAY : The Other McCain
March 20th, 2010 @ 8:51 am

[…] About CBO ‘Estimate’RAMMING SPEED! Democrats Prepare for ‘Really Stupid and Futile Gesture’CBO Performs Voodoo Math and Other Undead Zombie Health Care UpdatesDennis Kucinich to Vote ‘Yes’ and Other Updates on Zombie Health Care Bill Undead Zombie Health […]