The Other McCain

"One should either write ruthlessly what one believes to be the truth, or else shut up." — Arthur Koestler


Posted on | August 4, 2012 | 119 Comments

This is an emergency post. Driving back from the AFP Defending the Dream Summit in D.C., I pulled off the freeway and logged on at a Burger King to get this online as quickly as possible: Mitt Romney must choose Wisconsin Rep. Paul Ryan as his vice-presidential nominee, period.

There is no time now to fully explain the emergency nature of this post, but let me quickly make three points:

  1. My hatred of media “veepstakes” speculation is well-known. When I turn on the TV and see a bunch of pundits talking about who might get the vice-presidential nomination, I turn the channel. It’s a bunch of useless noise, and I can’t stand to watch it. Nevertheless, a sudden crisis makes it imperative that I speak out.
  2. My first choice — and what I think was the most obvious choice — was Florida Sen. Marco Rubio. However, the word among Republican sources is that there were problems with Rubio in terms of vetting. Loath as I am to repeat this, I’ve heard talk that because Rubio is the son of immigrants, there is concern that this might cost Republicans the “Birther” vote. Crazy? Yeah. But whatever the basis for the objections, the general belief is that there is indeed some sort of vetting issue. And so the smart money says that, although Rubio is still officially on the “short list,” he’s unlikely to be the final choice.
  3. The emergency? Two words: Tim Pawlenty.

Friday night, I was talking to some top activists at the AFP summit and one of them assured me that the word among Minnesota Republicans is that T-Paw is at the top of Romney’s VP list, all but guaranteed to be the running mate. Do I have to explain why this shocked me?

So shocked was I, in fact, that I refused to believe it. Certainly, the smart guys at Team Mitt could see the obvious arguments against T-Paw. But then Saturday, I talked to some well-informed D.C.-based operatives and they, too, said they’d heard that Pawlenty was top of the list.

Now I was truly concerned. Dear God, not T-Paw!

Driving home, this worry weighed heavily on my thoughts, and so I called a well-connected and experienced conservative journalist to talk about it — and he’d heard the same basic thing: Pawlenty might already have the VP spot locked up, said my friend, who happens to be a supporter of Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal. According to my friend, the word is that T-Paw is at the top of the list, with Ohio Sen. Rob Portman the nearest rival. And this is even worse news. While I like Portman OK, he’s a Bush guy, and we don’t need any ghosts of the Bush administration haunting the GOP in 2012.

So if Rubio has been more or less eliminated from consideration, as my sources suggest, we’ve got to do something to stop this crazy talk about a Romney-Pawlenty ticket. You can’t beat somebody with nobody, and of the remaining guys on the short list, Paul Ryan is the obvious pick.

He’s an Irish Catholic from the Midwest, a hero of deficit hawks, young and handsome, and pre-approved by Bill Kristol, who deems Ryan “the Republican party’s intellectual leader.”

This is, I repeat, an emergency, because Kristol says Mitt’s VP pick could be announced as early as Wednesday, or more likely Aug. 13-15. So if conservatives are going to push back against an ill-advised choice of Pawlenty, we’ve got to start pushing now, and pushing hard as hell.

Ali Akbar started a hashtag, #GiveUsRyan, so you can tell @MittRomney you want @RepPaulRyan as VP. Make it happen!

UPDATE: Wow! Bobby Jindal, himself a short-list candidate for VP, praises Paul Ryan at the Red State Gathering. Momentum!

UPDATE II: Twitchy has more from the Red State Gathering:

Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal, himself often mentioned as a top-tier candidate for vice president, today recommended Wisconsin Congressman Paul Ryan for the job.
Speaking this afternoon at RedState Gathering 2012 in Jacksonville, Fla., Jindal’s message of responsible spending and education reform had plenty of attendees sold on him as the vice presidential candidate. . . .
Asked by Breitbart’s Larry O’Connor his pick for vice president, though, Jindal named Ryan as his favorite of “a lot of great choices.” “Paul Ryan has been specific, bold and courageous in his budget plans,” said Jindal.

Linked by Jackie Wellfonder and the Daley Gatorthanks!



  • Bob Belvedere

    There might not be elections in November.

  • Bob Belvedere

    Here’s part of the problem: methinks Romney and his crew are going to do everything they can to avoid a McCain/Palin situation [rightly or wrongly].

    In other words, Willard is going to pick someone who is not going to overshadow him.

    Mr. Pawlenty would fit that bill for Team Willard.

    I think we have to put pressure on him to go for someone older who is conservative, who will not be a threat to us in eight years, but who is not flashy.  Paul Ryan [in addition to, as Adjoran correctly points out, not possessing any executive experience yet] is flash at this point.

    Is there any former Governor out there with some foreign policy experience who is solid but not flashy?  That’s who we should get behind.

  • Beeblebrocs

    Have to disagree. The veep choice is critical to the future of the GOP. Romney’s veep would be the presumptive nominee in 2020. The only question Romney should ask himself is ” would this guy be a strong successor to me”.

    That ain’t Pawlenty.

  • Beeblebrocs

    Until they become the nominee for POTUS. Then it makes all the difference.

    The number one thing the electorate is looking for in a vp nominee is how they would govern as president. Meanwhile, the base is looking at is whether they’ll be useful on the campaign trail.

  • Beeblebrocs

    I so agree with you Alec.

    Romney needs to pick someone who is:

    Presidential (i.e. will be a good candidate in 2020)
    Smart and articulate
    Has exec experience
    Is a conservative
    Is not in congress (experience in congress is a negative)

    If these were the criteria then there are only two choices:

    Palin (which will never happen plus she would take the slot)

  • Beeblebrocs

    Palin *wouldn’t* take the slot.

  • higgins1990

     ^ that’s what I’d bet on, if I was a bettin’ man.

  • K-Bob

    You folks have to start giving me grief over my typos. Ignore the regulars. Beat me with a baseball bat. I nneed it, apperentlie.

  • Bob Belvedere

    How can I when I have my own to worry about?!?

  • Pingback: Panic Time in Hopeville: GOP/Romney Report Record July Fundraising : The Other McCain()

  • CPAguy

    Herman Cain!

  • Evi L. Bloggerlady
  • Pingback: R.S. McCain surrenders, acknowledges Wisconsin’s superiority « The TrogloPundit()

  • K-Bob

     “It’s dead, Jim” (404 error)

  • Pingback: Hey, @MittRomney: This #GiveUsRyan Hashtag Is Becoming Kinda Popular : The Other McCain()

  • Pingback: A Trillion In New Taxes? | Daily Pundit()

  • Pingback: The Hashtag That Changed History : The Other McCain()

  • Pingback: Romney tabs Paul Ryan as his VP « The Daley Gator()

  • Pingback: FMJRA 2.0: Saturday Night With The Snakes : The Other McCain()