It would probably be libelous to call somebody a “pill-peddling quack,” so you should try to avoid doing that:
Attorneys for 24-year-old James Holmes disclosed he was a “psychiatric patient” of Dr. Lynne Fenton in a court motion Friday, as they sought to discover the source of leaks to media outlets that he sent the psychiatrist a package containing a notebook with descriptions of an attack.
The revelation is the first indication that Holmes may have sought help before the rampage that killed 12 people and wounded 58. . . .
The University of Colorado’s website identified Fenton as the medical director of the school’s Student Mental Health Services. An online resume stated that she sees 10 to 15 graduate students a week for medication and psychotherapy, as well as 5 to 10 patients in her general practice as a psychiatrist. Schizophrenia was listed as one of her research interests.
Fenton worked for the U.S. Air Force in Texas as an acupuncturist before joining the University of Colorado in 2005.
Wait — an acupuncturist? The medical director of your university Student Mental Health Service is an acupuncturist? And she’s been disciplined by the Colorado Medical Board?
Records show Fenton has faced some trouble in her career. She was disciplined by the Colorado Medical Board in 2004 for prescribing herself Xanax while her mother was dying, state records show. She also was disciplined for prescribing the sleep aid Ambien and the allergy medicine Claritin for her husband, and painkillers for an employee who suffered from chronic headaches.
I’m sure Dr. Fenton is a nice person and I’m sure advocates of acupuncture will say it’s a perfectly legitimate and scientific type of treatment. The problem here is the liability incurred by the University of Colorado in hiring Dr. Fenton, now that one of her former patients is accused of shooting 70 people, 12 of whom died.
Acupuncture is . . . well, exotic would be one word for it.
If you’re a lawyer preparing to defend the university in a situation like this, do you want to have to explain acupuncture to a jury? Fairly or not, a lot of people hear “acupuncture” and classify it with herbal remedies, aromatherapy, and other such not-quite-standard holistic stuff.
It’s like finding out that your financial advisor is consulting tarot cards.
We can presume that most of the patients Dr. Fenton saw at the university Mental Health Service were routine stress-and-depression cases: The student with a Prozac prescription who needs a monthly appointment to get ber prescription re-filled, and so forth. Nothing major that would create a liability for the university if something goes wrong, and so anything problematic in Dr. Fenton’s background was no big deal — until one of her patients went on a murderous rampage. Now the university is a tort magnet, with the prospect of a jury being confronted with the question: Were university officials negligent in hiring as medical director of the Student Mental Health Service someone whom the plaintiffs’ attorneys will try to portray as a pill-peddling quack?
Of course, it’s unlikely any jury will ever hear such a case, because lawyers would advise the university to settle the claims out of court. And if this is how it plays out, then the taxpayers of Colorado will be on the hook for several million dollars’ worth of settlements.
Here’s the irony, though: The University of Colorado could not have expelled James Holmes for being a dangerous psycho, because that would have exposed the university to a claim that they were violating federal law by illegally discriminating against the mentally ill.
Society is being held hostage by the tort bar, so that plaintiffs’ lawyers are dictating the rules. There’s a word for this: crazy.
1. She’s more qualified than most MD in the VA and DoD. Acupuncture is like blogging – an exotic form of reporting.
2. Check her scope of practice. What is she allowed to do (school rules, insurance rules, Colorado and Federal rules)? If pushing pills and listening to a patient whine about not getting sorority dates because of his 8 hour a night WoW addiction is her limit, and she practiced to her limit, then the issue is not her.
Some elements of her history do not add up, or at least the timeline appears a bit confused.
She was disciplined by the Colorado Medical Board in 2004 for prescribing controlled substances to herself and immediate family (a no no in many, but not all states) and for treating an employee (a no no in a few states.) Indicating that she had her own private practice, at least in 2004.
Had she done those things on an Air Force base, even if only licensed in Colorado, Colorado medical regulations simply do not apply. On Federal land you are pretty much free to do whatever your job description says you can do, and if it is not expressly prohibited, it is generally OK (up until it becomes a specific problem.) And even then, if you cross the line it is exceptionally rare for a State board to get involved.
So, was the acupuncture just a side gig? That seems highly unusual, but maybe not impossible. The services typically prefer to use there own medical state of commissioned officers, but do contract out for specialty services as needed.
A search would seem to indicate that the Air Force’s interest in this practice has expanded.
http://tinyurl.com/blffa27
Also I wouldn’t be so quick to assume that acupuncture is going to be portrayed as quackery. While not a generally accepted part of western medicine, it is recognized as one of the less questionable types of alternative medical practices, and has been endorsed by the National Institutes of Health for some conditions. Given the apparent institutional acceptance of the practice on the part of the Air Force that avenue seem unproductive in the least. People are not going to lose their skepticism, but this isn’t going to convince them of quackery.
Also, why would the defense want to alienate the one person who probably has seen the most of what goes on in his mind? They cannot credibly argue she made him nuts, better to have her in agreement that he has always been nuts.
There are other questions in this: did she prescribe meds for him; was he perhaps not taking his meds; or worse, was he taking them and perhaps had an adverse reaction? Since her previous disciplines were for improper prescribing activities, I would wonder if she had prescribed anything in this case and if so, what?
I suppose if she took an exceptionally large acupuncture needle and hammered it deeply in his ear…it might have stopped him.
The problem is hindsight, foreseeability, and what she knew and when she knew it. Sort of like Eric Holder and Fast & Furious. Of course, in this case she probably will not have Barack Obama claiming executive privilege.
So is the Aurora shooter, while obviously deranged, faking insanity for a legal defense? Or is the issue a school mental health official who blew a chance to stop a mass murder through incompetence? Or was this just a tragedy that unfortunately everyone missed before it was too late? We do not know yet.
Present-day financial advisors might get better results from tarot. (“Citi? Here’s the Death card.”)
As for society being held hostage by the tort bar…how exactly? Of course there will be litigation over this shooting. But unless this shooter told her specifically he was going to be violent, she would have had little recourse to have stopped him (she would have been bound not to disclose anything he said).
But your premise is false. Society is not bound at all. The legislature in Colorado can change the rules if it finds the system is being abused. Granted lawyers in Colorado will resist it. Insurance companies will likely be all for it.
[…] includes working as an acupuncturist and being disciplined for her prescribing practices. (H/T, Stacy McCain) Dr. Fenton’s resume states that one of her interest is […]
I would just caution not jumping to final conclusions just yet. I do not think of acupuncture for mental illness (whiplash and sports medicine come to mind first for this sort of treatment) but it is not crazy in itself. The issue here (at least the primary one) is whether the shooter told her he had violent thoughts and she failed to act or report (which most mental health officials and even most attorneys are bound to do). The secondary one is if she prescribed some medication and then he had a bad reaction to it. We do not know that yet either. You can be sure teams of regulators and attorneys will be looking to find out.
As for who will be paying any tort claims (which will be brought by the victims of the shooting and their families)? I am going to guess the University and doctor have some sort of insurance in place. Barring policy limits getting tapped (which is possible), insurance will be paying.
There are many possible scenarios, and let’s understand that we’re dealing with one of those situations that invoke the Law of Large Numbers: If a psychiatrist treats sees 100 different patients a year for 10 years, for a cumulative total of 1,000 patients, and the frequency of mental patients engaging in criminal violence is 0.1%, the chances are that one ofthe psychiatrist’s patients will commit an act of criminal violence.
James Holmes is at the far edge of the tables of statistical probability — an outlier, an anomaly, a rare specimen. Very few psychiatrists have ever encountered a patient like that, and so very few have had experience in spotting the “warning signs” that their patient is at serious risk of committing mass murder.
The question in regard to the University of Colorado’s liability, however, is whether the university exercised “due diligence” in its selection and supervision of their Student Mental Health Service director. Was Dr. Fenton truly the most qualified applicant for the position? Were there any previous incidents during her tenure in that position which might have indicated that Dr. Fenton was not suitable for this role? Given the record of medical board complaints against here, I think it is reasonable to suppose that attorneys for the Aurora shooting victims might find something in the records of the Student Mental Health Service that would be damaging to the university.
And if such a lawsuit were brought, I’ll bet dollars to donuts the university would offer a settlement before the case ever got to the deposition phase. The downside risk — including the potential public-relations damage — of going to trial would be too great. The tort lawyers know this, which is why there is such an obvious likelihood that the university will be sued.
This is a different sort of case, and generally the cops have immunity for this sort of “mistake” but it seems a crying shame to deny this young lady her day in court. http://pjmedia.com/instapundit/147577/
Then again, maybe Stacy, I know this might be a stretch, but maybe she really is incompetent and this shooting could have been stopped. Of course, we do not know that yet.
I mean, UoC did hire and give tenure to Ward Churchill didn’t it?
http://www.theagitator.com/2012/07/29/cardinal-bernard-law-had-other-commitments/ She can always go back to working for the feds…
I will add that this might be one of those cases where the Peter Principle has deadly consequences. People routinely talk their way into jobs for which they are not ideally qualified, but usually the results are not fatal.
Think about Michael Brown, whose main “qualification” to be director of the Federal Emergency Management Agency was that he was a Republican lawyer who was buddies with Joe Allbaugh. OK, fine, so long as all that is necessary to the FEMA director’s job is routine bureaucratic administration, who cares? But then a Category 4 hurricane slams head-on into a major city, causing catastrophic damage and a nightmarish humanitarian crisis.
“Heckuva job, Brownie.”
In that kind of rare emergency, having a Peter Principle type in the key job brings disaster.
We do not know enough about the situation with James Holmes and Dr. Fenton to say that this is an equivalent scenario. But if there were any “warning signs” overlooked, and if there had been any previous indication that Dr. Fenton was not qualified to run the Student Mental Health Service . . .
“Heckuva job, Dr. Fenton.”
Is the doctor a member of the Protected classes?
http://www.americanthinker.com/2012/07/pro-murderer_mindset_of_the_new_york_times.html This is a damn fine article. FYI.
[…] and their families. Nice to see the Colorado taxpayers paying for voting socialist. Stolen from the Other McCain. Corruption, Crime, Dumbasses, FraudPermalink ← The Meta Roundup of Link […]
EBL:
If U of CO had not hired Dr. Fenton, they could have been sued. There are Federal, State, and University laws covering equal employment opportunities, with penalties if not followed.
That U of CO did hire Dr. Fenton, they will be sued.
If the movie theater denied Holmes access to the theater, it would have been sued. Civil rights apply to all. There’s no “Colored Only” type restrictions.
That the movie theater provided access to Holmes, it will be sued.
If the gunseller denied Holmes access to a rifle after he passed the FEDERAL checks, the gunseller would’ve been sued.
That the gunseller sold weapons to Holmes, he, the gun manufacturers, ammo manufacturers and providers, and the Gun Range Owner who failed have Holmes arrested will all be sued.
The only winners are lawyers. They write the laws and go to court to ensure the laws are enforced or modified. They go to court when the laws are broken, or enforced properly. When someone melts down, anyone and everyone in the area, or remotely associated with the scene become chum for lawyers.
Don’t be surprised to see Holmes’s diet, even hair colorist, considered for cash haul. It all started with the first judge to rolled a Good Samaratin.
” If the movie theater denied Holmes access to the theater, it would have been sued.”
Er…he entered through a fire door, evidently. The theater didn’t deny him access; and of course it’s kind of a ridiculous scenario if you start thinking about it.
“Hi, I’m not here to see the movie, but to shoot up the patrons. Can I get a discount?”
“Fenton also is a member of the campus-based “behavioral assessment and threat
assessment team,” which helps faculty and staff deal with “individuals who may
be threatening, disruptive or otherwise problematic,” according to that group’s
website.”
http://freenorthcarolina.blogspot.com/2012/07/colo-shooting-suspect-was-under-care-of.html#comment-form
What is seldom mentioned is that Brownie realized he was out of his depth and just got out of the way of his subordinates. The disaster of Katrina was a failure of state and local government all the way, from the looting of monies meant to maintain the levees to a lazy in competent city leadership who printed a disaster plan but never bothered to read it, and city employees who abandoned their neighbors.
Of course, those folks were Democrats, so we don’t talk about that.
No doubt tort attorneys will be drawn to potential deep pocket parties in this case like pirañas to a injured capybara. My point is the Colorado legislature can control torts through legislation. And not all civil lawsuits are unjustified.
That is very true.
I believe he might actually be very seriously mentally ill. I also believe he could be one of the very rare ones who has two different issues: he might be a psychopath who developed schizophrenia.
I would wonder about the circumstances of his adoption. For example according to this study:
http://www.health.am/psy/more/adoption-studies/
“One of the first large adoption studies was the Heston Study in 1966. Heston identified 47 adopted children whose biological mothers had schizophrenia. He compared these children to a group of children from the same foster homes whose biological mothers did not have schizophrenia. Heston found that 16.6 percent of the children of schizophrenic mothers became schizophrenic as adults, compared to none of the control children.
Thus, even though none of the children were raised by schizophrenic parents, the children who had schizophrenia in their biological families were more likely to develop the disorder.”
The age of onset is also about right.
Also psychopathy among adopted children, particularly those who were separated from their mothers at a very young age is more common than in the general population.
I would say that the very FIRST thing that should be done is have every single one of the people she has been seeing at that University be screened by someone else who has had more experience outside of acupuncture in psychotherapy.
Stacy, being an acupuncturist is not a disqualifying history for an MD. There are extensive studies showing acupuncture an effective treatment. Prescribing for your family was common practice 20 years ago. Modern psychiatric practice involves, yes, both talk therapy and and medication, even if you can snark about “pill-pushing quacks”. And you come back in a comment and note that law of large numbers comes in here: mass-murder is a very rare and (therefore) not well understood condition. There’s no pathognomonic indicator for it.
So basically, what the fuck is your point?
I think Charles Whitman, the guy who shot up the UT-Austin campus from a tower back in the Sixties, had a university psychiatrist, to whom he’d mentioned his violent fantasies. Might be worthwhile finding out what their liability was back then.
She’s female, so yes on at least one.
Stacy, can the Peter Principle really apply when we routinely give positions supposedly determined by merit to people depending on skin color?
Abandoned? Try actively looted their neighbors. On TV, yet.
Lack of experience on the field would be what I draw from it. It would be like hiring a proctologist as head of the cardiology department. They are both MDs but have very different specialties.
WTF could ANY psychiatrist have done? Under current law it is virtually impossible to confine a patient until AFTER he has committed a crime. The most that can be done is an observation period of 24-48 hours but there is little anyone can do to keep them beyond that.
It’s just stupid to go about seeking someone to blame. Why not blaming his Mummy for taking him to the circus when he was four and traumatized by a scary clown?
There is one person to blame for this massacre. He planned it out meticulously and kept it secret, even to the point of buying his weapons and ammo from different places over a period of months to avoid suspicion. That alone proves he knew it was wrong.
There are plenty of crazy people. Very few end up killing anyone. When they do, don’t invent someone else to take the blame for their bad acts.
Prescribing an antibiotic or a birth control pill or some other such thing for a family member or yourself won’t get you disciplined; it may be frowned upon but it is still pretty common practice. Xanax and Ambien are controlled substances. Big difference.
Society is being held hostage by the tort bar…
I maintain that this country started going to hell in the mid-19th Century when the Temperance Movement stopped us from being held as hostages to the Whiskey Bar.
Free Whiskey and Ice Cream! Forget about the health care.
I think that is exactly Stacy’s point. Doctor Needles will end up, via the UoC and any insurance, paying some tort claims of the victims.
But I would let the thing play out. Universities (especially public ones) have some protections (more than you think), doctors are actually (in most jurisdictions) pretty hard to sue and get a judgment against, and both judges and jurors are generally skeptical of weak liability theories.
I do not want to generalize. Adoption is generally a good thing and I would like to see more of it (the foster system sucks). But the pool that puts up kids for adoption includes some people who probably should not be having kids in the first place.
I am not surprised by that. Schizophrenia is not believed to be acquired but generally happens (probably genetically although we are unsure of the exact triggers for it).
You’re a lawyer, aren’t you?
I believe what we are seeing here is the sort of “cascade” failure of several different things lining up to cause a catastrophe, OR it is possibly a very well thought out plan to get away with murder.
Cascade failure:
1. Fenton did not recognize the severity of what she was dealing with or did no know how to properly treat it maybe allowing warning signs to go unnoticed or left unexplored. Might another doctor have been able to recognize that he was dangerous?
2. The package was not delivered to it intended recipient until after the shooting even though it was sent in plenty of time. Had this been delivered in a timely manner, would it have made a difference?
Manipulation:
1. Holmes knew or suspected Fenton was marginally qualified and thought he could use her to establish a paper trail of having seen a psychiatrist to establish an insanity defense.
2. Holmes knew or suspected that such a package would not be delivered until after the shooting. Was she on vacation or at a seminar or something and he knew she wouldn’t be back until Monday? Could he be attempting to establish an insanity defense but knew or suspected that nothing would be done until after the deed was done?
My engineering experience says that catastrophes are often the result of multiple failures that just happen to all line up in the same direction. Rarely does one single failure result in something like this.
For example, we might be talking about a much worse event had Holmes’ assault rifle not jammed AND police arrested him nearly immediately after he exited the theater because his explosives-rigged apartment failed to provide the required distraction for emergency personnel. Was he simply going back to the car for more ammo, different ammo drum magazine, or to travel to another location to continue the carnage? Might has plan have been to kill every single person in that theater? My guess is he planned to shoot them with the rifle. The shotgun was to be used if someone started shooting back at him. He would simply have to point it in the general direction of the fire and knock down whoever was shooting at him. The pistol would have been his “last resort” weapon should he have to run for it and drop the others or in case of something at close quarters. His rifle jammed forcing him to use the other weapons more than he had planned. He might have been simply going to get more ammo. His apartment bomb plan failed, allowing emergency responders to get to the scene in a hurry and arrest him.
Even with his plan we see multiple failures greatly reducing the carnage. Did multiple failures on our side allow it, or is it all part of a manipulation ruse? That’s going to be something that has to be explored with the experts.
Isn’t the Colorado legislature made up of lawyers? If so, your argument makes for a good theoretical discussion, but no lawyer will ever take any action to limit lawyers.
And Ms. Deeley: true enough, but then the argument becomes one of the theater followed the law by making the theater escapable, which is the law, but by following the law, it provided entrance to a murderer and is therefore liable.
The law is a no-win situation for anyone other than lawyers.
Charles Whitman, it turned out, had a highly aggressive brain tumor ( glioblastoma ) which likely played a role in his behavior.
I am a cow.
But I would wait and see if some crazy avalanche of tort litigation results from this.
I don’t know if you could say that this is an acupuncture problem-
Here biography also says she taught evidence based medicine classes for residences! And she has done much research into conventional psychiatric meds.
R-3 Evidence-Based Medicine – Co-taught weekly 90 minute course for R3 residentsSelected Peer-Reviewed Publications:
Roth EJ. Fenton LL. Gaebler-Spira DJ. Frost FS. Yarkony GM. Superior mesenteric artery syndrome in acute traumatic quadriplegia: case reports and literature review. Archives of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation. 72(6):417-20, 1991 May.
Green D. Lee MY. Lim AC. Chmiel JS. Vetter M. Pang T. Chen D. Fenton L. Yarkony GM. Meyer PR Jr. Prevention of thromboembolism after spinal cord injury using low-molecular-weight heparin. Annals of Internal Medicine. 113(8):571-4, 1990 Oct 15.
Geary GG. Fenton L. Cheng G. Smith GT. Siu B. McNamara JJ. Failure of pretreatment with propranolol to reduce the zone of myocardial infarction after 2 hours of coronary occlusion in the primate heart. American Journal of Cardiology. 52(5):615-20, 1983 Sep 1.
Grants and Contracts:
Reward Processing in Schizophrenia: the Effects of Aripiprazole and Risperidone, 2008-present
A functional MRI investigation
False Pattern Recognition in Schizophrenia, 2009 – present
Involvement of the dopaminergic reward system.
Functional MRI Correlates of Overeating in Schizophrenia Treated with Olanzapine, 2009 – present
[…] is now pointed have been falsely accused, and just as assuredly that makes little difference to the tort lawyers involved, who will back their clients as credulously as Gloria Allred standing behind Sandra Fluck […]
There is no question but that schizophrenia has a genetic component. It tends to occur in highly-creative families, and can be considered to be creativity gone wild. Think of VanGogh and Philip K Dick, among many others.
The schizophrenic brain can be compared to a computer with random missed instructions — a few errors can lead to brilliant leaps of logic, numerous errors lead to illogic, vast numbers of errors lead to mental paralysis.
Age of recognition of the illness is usually late teens/early twenties but the signs are there much earlier, simply not comprehended.
Schizophrenics who commit seriously antisocial acts are rare, probably corresponding to the percentage of “normal” individuals who are antisocial. In other words, schizophrenia interferes with judgment but doesn’t automatically make a sufferer “mean.”
Exactly. Brown got the blame, but didn’t deserve it. If anything, there were more pre-postioned relief supplies and teams for Katrina than for any prior hurricane.
But it is impossible to plan precisely for the level of Democratic stupidity and incompetence which ensued.
I believe you are mistaken about the state of the law on liability. The theater’s insurer may settle nuisance suits for a nominal sum to avoid litigation, but there is nothing they could have done to prevent this within the law and nothing they did which was in any way negligent, at least as the facts are known.
I don’t know the composition of the Colorado legislature, but the voters elected them.
Once again, unless the shrink had specific knowledge of an imminent crime, it would have been illegal and unethical for her to communicate her concerns to anyone. And even if she knew he was a complete nutbar on the verge of a psychotic break, the law doesn’t permit forcible sedation or incarceration unless the patient is a clear and imminent danger to himself or others. There just isn’t much that can be done within the law before someone commits a crime.
Not every bad and horrible thing can be prevented.