Ace of Spades Smacks Charles Johnson in a Post Every New* Blogger Should Read

* And by “new,” I mean if you haven’t been at it
since Ace started with a Blogspot site in 2003.

When trying to explain the principle of reciprocal linkage (Rule 2), I’ve often wanted to quote a post Ace of Spades wrote about three years ago, in which he explained how you link somebody so as to throw traffic, how to quote and hat-tip, etc. But alas, I couldn’t find the post.

Now, however, Ace has reprised that theme in a memorable pimp-slapping of Charles Johnson:

Let me talk about “swiping stories.” Johnson believes that if he throws in a lame hat-tip at the end of a post, he hasn’t “swiped a story,” because he’s given you attribution.
That’s not the case. A lame hat-tip at the end of a post covers one’s ass, I suppose, in terms of attribution, but it fails to do what a proper link is supposed to do: Throw some traffic.
Some blogs are deliberately “gateway blogs,” throwing out traffic wide and far in general furtherance of good-guy blogger boosterism. . . .
On the other hand, some blogs are very jealous and ungenerous about throwing links and traffic to “competitors.” Some blogs fancy themselves not “gateway blogs” but “destination blogs,” and attempt to set themselves up as the only blog you need to read.
Not a portal, then, but a terminus. . . .

Anybody who has read this blog long enough knows that Ace is my blogging role model. Back when I was hopelessly trapped in the stifling straitjacket of Washington journalism, I envied Ace because he could say exactly what he wanted — and be hugely successful!

My admiration for Ace is so enthusiastic as to be kinda creeptastic and stalkerish, like a teenage girl chasing the Jonas Brothers. Yet he is so merciful that not once has he threatened to take out a restraining order against me. And he actually links me once in a while.

So read the whole thing.

Uh . . . I’ll be in my bunk.

UPDATE: To put the Ace/LGF situation in context, some explanation is in order. There was a minor media-bias kerfuffle this past week in regard to the Gaza “Freedom Flotilla,” and I didn’t blog about it because the source was Little Green Footballs. But it got picked up in the media and everybody else blogged about it, including Yid With Lid:

Reuters is now doctoring its pictures from the violence aboard the Guerrilla Flotilla.

YWL got linked at Hot Air, and this prompted Charles Johnson to go thermonuclear on Allahpundit:

“So what kind of vindictive, unprofessional, unethical creep would write about a story and give all the credit to other people, knowing full well that the story originated at LGF?
“The dishonest dirtbag goes by the name of ‘Allahpundit,’ and he writes for Hot Air.”

To which Allahpundit replied:

It seems I’m “scum,” a “thief,” and a “dishonest dirtbag” because I thought Sammy Benoit had found the initial photo of Reuters cropping out weapons. Turns out it was Charles Johnson at LGF who broke the story; Sammy’s post only mentioned him in connection with the second photo. So here’s the official correction from a scummy dirtbag thief.

Paleo Pat at Political Byline called attention to this:

Has this man forgotten just how badly he stabbed the right in the back? Has Charles Johnson forgotten how badly that he defamed Pamela Geller, by calling her a Nazi Sympathizer? This happened more than once by the way; the first time almost ruined her blogger career.

OK, then Ace linked Political Byline and pointed out that Charles Johnson has been known to swipe a story without proper credit — citing as one example an occasion when LGF hogged the credit for a Dan Riehl item.

Dan’s thrown a few light jabs at CJ the past couple of days — including one about the Geller PayPal situation — but he hasn’t gotten rough with LGF and probably won’t. But, oh, if he ever did . . .

UPDATE II: Now here we go. I hadn’t bothered to look at the post that provoked Ace’s latest response, but it perfectly exemplifies what went wrong with Charles Johnson:

Johnson recounts a dust-up in which Steve Gilbert at Sweetness & Light accused Johnson of “stealing one of his stories,” an accusation Johnson denied. But when Gilbert, per CJ, “threatened to ‘ruin my reputation’ with other bloggers” Johnson “preemptively wrote emails to several other bloggers.”

Now, I don’t know the backstory there, and Johnson uses it as pretext to publish private correspondence with Ace — a vicious betrayal, and a bell that can never be unrung. Yet that’s not the real “tell” here.

Why on earth was Charles Johnson so concerned about what another blogger might say about him to other bloggers — especially when Johnson himself at that time (March 2008) had been waging a merciless online vendetta against Pamela Geller and Robert Spencer for six months?

Kind of thin-skinned, don’t you think?

Can you say “guilty conscience,” boys and girls?

Proprietary rage over which blogger “stole” what story from whom is a routine fixture of the blogosphere. Being obsessed with one’s reputation to the point where you’re sending back-channel e-mails to other bloggers to “preemptively” defend yourself from an accusation of story-swiping . . .

To quote Allahpundit: Dude.

With the exception of my own reporting, nearly everything I blog about comes from either Memeorandum, Google News or Twitter. How the story gets to those places, I don’t much care. If either Instapundit or Ace links a story that gets picked up by other bloggers, that story will usually show up at Memeorandum — which seldom credits Ace or Insty, who may thereby be cheated out of deserved hat-tips.

Bloggers that big, however, usually have better things to do than to worry whether they get credited for every story they blog. And certainly it would be insanely time-consuming to keep up with the soap-opera plot-twists of which bloggers are mad at other bloggers.

That’s why it’s so bizarre to discover that Charles Johnson was “preemptively” e-mailing other bloggers that way in 2008. Why would Johnson worry that other bloggers might credit Steve Gilbert’s accusations?

With that e-mail, Johnson betrayed a profound narcissistic tendency. For Johnson then to wait more than two years to retaliate against Ace by publishing a private e-mail is unquestionably sociopathic.

Picture it, reader: Charles Johnson, once one of the most heralded members of the blogsophere, sitting there with archived e-mails from years ago, poring over his cache to retrieve and publish this e-mail he solicited while endeavoring to protect his own reputation.

Sick. And not merely sick, but evil.

The Classic Liberal Is a Good Blog

Just switched the FMJRA Award to The Classic Liberal, which is a good excuse for a brief Rule 2 seminar. Earlier today, I got an e-mail from a journalist who was doing a story about how the Dale Petersen video went “viral.” The reporter asked me why I called out Gawker for failing to give me a hat-tip on the video:

Adrien Chen at Gawker can’t bring himself to give me a hat-tip for being the first to blog about “The Most American Thing Ever Made,” but I’ll count this as one more uncredited mitzvah for the Clown Prince of the Right-Wing Blogosphere.

I linked Gawker in the process of taking notice of the non-hat-tip, and made a joke of it, because I don’t want to become one of those humorless bloggers — no need to name names — who spend way too much time compiling their Enemies List.

My own Enemies List is extremely short, not because I’m so merciful and magnanimous, but because I did too much dope back in the ’70s and don’t have enough spare memory cells to keep track of every douchebag who has screwed me over. Much less do I have time to keep track of the douchebags who have screwed over my friends. So I’ll sometimes link a douchebag and accidentally piss off my friends who expect me to keep track of their Enemies List.

Lots of my friends consider Dave Weigel a douchebag, for example. But I know Dave, we’ve covered the same stories — including the insane crucible of NY-23 — and he is the only big-time MSM blogger who includes me on his blogroll. Just imagine how that must piss off Charles Johnson, and you understand that Weigel can’t possibly be more than 97% douchebag. So there is at least some hope for his redemption before he reaches Rule 6 territory.

It takes persistent effort to make my Enemies List. Very few people can devote the kind of career-long effort that David Brooks has made toward becoming the Douchebag King and even Brooks occasionally writes something that isn’t completely wrong. The world would still be a better place if Brooks were air-dropped from a C-130 over Waziristan without a parachute, but that’s not necessarily the first thing on my “to do” list when I seize total power in a coup d’etat and become Maximum Leader of the revolutionary junta.

My e-mail reply to the inquiring journalist  involved a brief discouse on Rule 2 as an expression of the beneficial networking effects of reciprocal linkage, my concept of the blogosphere as a collaborative enterprise, “No Blog Is An Island,” etc. When I finished with that e-mail, I resolved to deliver the FMJRA Award to the most recent blog to have trackbacked here.

The Classic Liberal was the lucky linker, and I want to take the opportunity to praise the general design of his site. It’s clean and simple, with a nice overall look. It is easy to read — the type isn’t eye-straining small — with lots of links.

Good blogging, in other words. And he linked here, which is the very essence of good blogging in my book.

After the coup d’etat, there will only be so many crew members on that C-130 to Waziristan, and the Maximum Leader will be in charge of deciding who gets the honor of kicking the payload out the rear door. Keep that in mind.

Fantastic Mint Juleps Revive Americans

by Smitty

This week’s FMJRA salutes intrepid road warrior Stacy McCain, going that extra couple hundred miles to bring that crucial back story as only he can:
LIVE from Orleans Parish!

President Heartsleeve

After making an ass of himself with a private citizen over nuclear opinions, this is my new name for BHO. Maybe there will be a parody tune to Greensleeves at some point.
If You Can’t Bedazzle With Brains, Baffle With Bacon Sandwich

The Price of Press-Corps Fellatio

Looking to November

A site to cheer you up, if you’re a downcounter like me, or perhaps motivate you to higher levels of effort to reclaim the country.

Ambassador John Bolton Endorses Patrick Murray For VA-8

    VIDEO: Interview With Vernon Parker, AZ-3 Republican Candidate

    VIDEO: Wayne Allyn Root at Searchlight

      VIDEO: New Marco Rubio Ad; PLUS: Rudy Giuliani vs. Arianna Huffington

      John McCain Gets His Queeg On

      Nevada Voters to Hopeless Harry Reid: ‘We’re Just Not That Into You’

      Stormy Daniels, GOP Porn Star

      Vernon Parker: Trained by the Best

      The Rest of the Story

      Here are the bulk our our uncategorized bits.
      How About A Union of Liberty-Conscious Americans?

      Obama’s New Low

      Normblog Profiles Fausta

      Obama Talks Jobs, While Unemployment Stays at 9.7 Percent

        Who Is Brent Budowsky, and Why Should Anybody Care What He Thinks?

          Harpoon Him!

            DailyKos Poll Puts McCain Over Hayworth

              Respectfully Disagreeing With Andrew Breitbart Here

              Liz Carter for Congress: Because It’s Time to Tip Over and Capsize Hank Johnson

              Two Portions Of Chicken Embracing Cheesy Pork

              MoveOn.org vs. ‘Blue Dog’ Barrow

              One of These Things Is Not Like the Other

              Liberal Fantasies vs. Economic Reality

              Tea Party Alert: Harry Reid Will Launch Three-Day Nevada Bus Tour Monday

              Economic Stimulus Meets Education

                Why I Think ‘Settled Law’ As An Excuse For Federal Over-reach Is Insufficient

                Progress On The Long March Through The Institutions

                  As If the Media Needed Another Reason to Hate Sarah Palin

                  Alex Giannoulias and the Chicago Way

                    More Economic Reality

                    Who Is Ken Buck?

                      Bad to Worse for Sorry Charlie Crist

                      Suck of the Titans

                        Shootout at the RNC Corral

                        Word Association With Joe The Plumber Goes Unwell For John McCain @3:40

                          Bedtime Viewing

                          Kathy Shaidle and ‘Casual Bigotry’

                          When It Rains, It Pours for RNC

                          ‘All Caveats’

                          A. Because He Blogrolled Me

                            I Would Not Accuse Sen. Coburn Of Kool-Aid Quaffing

                              Irony And The Streisand Effect

                                American Resurgence Continues Apace

                                Hey, Has Anybody Else Noticed That Bob Belvedere Is a Persistent Blogwhore?

                                Sarah Palin, Newt Gingrich, Sean Hannity and . . .

                                Carol Swain vs. the ‘Tolerance Mafia’

                                  He’s Got a Ph.D. and a Nobel Prize, But . . .

                                  How About That Rep. Thaddeus McCotter?

                                  Veronique de Rugy Deserves A Medal

                                  And a shout to Paco for a link to the archives of justice.

                                  Other FMJRA Outings:

                                  Social Train Wrecks

                                  Finally, we’ll take any linkage we can get, but these unsavory stories merit a trip to the end.
                                  Jesse James Enters Rehab, Seeking Treatment for Skank Addiction

                                  Celebrity Meltdown Update

                                  That’s your FMJRA. Thanks to all who link. Find your local Tea Party and get there on Thursday.