by Smitty
Jazz Shaw points out that you need a fairly stupid mark for Valerie Jarrett to be successful in her sales pitch. Valerie, if we think you’re selling used cars, as when the name Roberts comes up, you need to go away. You attempts to whitewash Kagan’s record WRT the military is quite offensive.
But if it’s OK not to think that John Roberts deserved support for the SCOTUS, then we should feel perfectly content, by Valerie’s measure, to think Kagan unworthy of an appointment, as well. Thanks, Valerie. Tool.
As Ramesh Ponnuru notes:
Elena Kagan helped to keep military recruiters from having equal access to the Harvard campus–based on what she called “the military’s policy” on don’t ask, don’t tell. When Congress voted to deny Defense Department funds to universities that discriminate against the military, she joined an effort to fight the law (called the Solomon amendment) in court. In effect, she was arguing that the school had a constitutional right to get government funding while discriminating against military recruiters. The Supreme Court ruled unanimously against the universities.
So on this issue it is hard to argue that Kagan was within the judicial mainstream. Her position is, additionally, hard to defend.
And then there is the smoking artillery that one expects may be found in the Clinton memos.
If we can’t have NoOneBarack Nominates on the court, it would be better to draft Hillary. One or two decades of Lefty nitwittery would be preferable to three+. Also, the possibility of a decent Secretary of State exists–could Colin Powell pinch hit until 2012?
The preceding rant is here.
Update: Sweet. A Second Amendment history only the ACLU could love.
Update II: Heh. Krauthammer:
On Arlen Specter having voted against Kagan for solicitor general, now shifting his position:
You almost feel sorry for Arlen Specter. I mean: Almost. This is a guy of so many twists and turns and retreats and swerves and reverses. It reminds me of a line in a Graham Greene novel where he speaks of his protagonist who says: “I prefer to tell the truth. It’s easier to memorize.”
Specter‘s got a lot of memorizing to do . . .